8 September 2024

Keeping people out of prison has a big payoff for society and taxpayers

| Ian Bushnell
Join the conversation
33
Prison

The Alexander Maconochie Centre. Breaking the cycle of incarceration for many prisoners would be profound. Photo: Michelle Kroll.

In the shadows of the election, the ACT Government has announced two initiatives that it hopes will not only make the community safer but rein in the population of the Territory’s jail and the costs associated with supporting it.

Attorney-General Shane Rattenbury launched the second phase of the government’s Justice Reinvestment program, which will focus on early intervention and diversion, the goal being early intervention when offenders are at greatest risk (which could be through health and education assistance) and supporting people exiting prison so they didn’t return (through housing support).

Mr Rattenbury revealed a telling statistic – that the cost of housing someone at the Alexander Maconochie Centre for a year was $198,000. Do the crime, do the time may be a catchy phrase but the reality is simply sending people to jail again and again is not only failing to deter criminal behavior but is also not sustainable.

READ ALSO National Cabinet puts serious money on the table to help address domestic violence

The idea of Justice Reinvestment – spending money on programs to keep people out of jail and reap a fiscal as well as social dividend – has its roots in conservative Texas where the soaring cost of incarceration was getting out of hand.

Measures already introduced have reduced recidivism by almost 20 per cent since 2018, and the government is committed to continuing on this path to working with organisations and the community to tailor programs that will deal with the underlying causes of crime and offer support to people so they do not go back through the revolving prison door.

Police will say that the AMC is filled with regular offenders who are well known to them and, tragically, as time goes on, their children. Breaking this cycle of behaviour in a small jurisdiction like the ACT would have profound effects.

The other announcement was the decision to join the rest of the country in introducing electronic monitoring of people wearing trackable ankle bracelets while on bail, parole and community orders.

The Canberra Liberals had already promised to do this for serious offenders on bail out of concern at offences committed while people are free awaiting their hearing or trial.

But it’s the number of unsentenced detainees, including those awaiting trial, in the AMC that is alarming – a little less than half (46.5 per cent) of the total prison population at 30 June 2023. The ACT has the highest rate of people on remand of all Australian jurisdictions.

If electronic monitoring can provide some assurance to the community that alleged offenders can still be free but under sufficient surveillance to minimise any chance of potential reoffending, that not only satisfies the presumption of innocence but eases pressure on the jail.

READ ALSO ACT Labor backs away from its own proposed reform to reduce pokies numbers to 1000

At the other end, electronic monitoring offers an opportunity to parole people safely and provide interventions to prevent reoffending.

The government is fully aware that for some offenders and offences, justice needs to be served in the form of appropriate penalties and the community needs to be protected.

But there is much to be gained by pursuing policies and practices that keep people out of prison – even if the main appeal will be to people’s hip pockets.

Join the conversation

33
All Comments
  • All Comments
  • Website Comments
LatestOldest

The greens are pushing for younger kids to vote, but not to do the time.

They’re either responsible or they’re not. Not just when they vote for you shane!

wildturkeycanoe3:28 pm 18 Sep 24

I think keeping some teenagers behind bars would have been beneficial for three bystanders at Canberra Centre. I am not surprised to read a 14 y.o. was on bail when it happened. There needs to be more disincentive to commit crime and issuing bail over and over again doesn’t seem to be working.

They need to start charging the parents and holding them responsible. As a minor I believe he would have been bailed to someone’s care( ?).

Consequences start at home.

Where did they get the over-inflated $198,000 per year??? Anyway, the people who committed the crime must work, not idle in prison. There is a lot of public work to be done.

I don’t believe them anymore when they talk about wanting to keep people out of prison and that want a better society. Who says that while, at the same, saying nothing at all about a junk culture, which can only be summed as extremely low brow?

You don’t get to have toxic art, education, politics and loose morals without having deleterious effects, and it’s time people started to accept this.

Ahh the simplicity of a headline.

Keeping people out of prison. Yup that works for those repeatedly burgled or those who experience the vandalism and hooning happening across our suburbs.

Yup this no prison policy is a big hit with crims and recidivist muppets.

“ If electronic monitoring can provide some assurance to the community” – if? No it does not provide an assurance to the community.

Stop rewarding bad behaviour and start looking after the community.

Well said Franco. Punishment means removal of freedoms for a long time. Feather punishments means “oh, so what if I kill someone. the Judge will give me a suspended sentence. Clearly those same Judges need to give harsher penalties for crimes involving the innocent. Everyone else-give them a day job commensurate with their abilities, outside jail with a leg bracelet, and bring them in at night. They would get an insight into what life could be like if they “got with the program”.

Agree of what you said. The victims seems to be second class citizens. The criminals gets promotion. What a joke.

Make prison far less attractive then. Foxtel and video games after your drugs is not a deterrent.

Daily Digest

Want the best Canberra news delivered daily? Every day we package the most popular Riotact stories and send them straight to your inbox. Sign-up now for trusted local news that will never be behind a paywall.

By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.