26 April 2024

Minister will need to live up to his name to get light rail vision back on track

| Ian Bushnell
Join the conversation
15

Transport Minister Chris Steel has a job on his hands to seize back the public transport initiative. Photo: Ian Bushnell.

Transport Minister Chris Steel returns from leave today with a pile of work on his desk and a big challenge to regain the initiative from the Canberra Liberals.

In his extended absence, the Liberals announced a reasonable public transport policy (coincidence?) and made merry with the fact that the vaunted new electric buses had not yet made it onto the roads.

Between a policy promising no light rail after stage 2A, a new busway and an expanded e-bus fleet, even including assembling them here one day, and labelling the latest Labor procurement as ‘ghost buses’, transport spokesperson Mark Parton grabbed the headlines and headspace of Canberrans.

Chief Minister Andrew Barr and City Services Minister Tara Cheyne stepped into the breach, but the damage was done.

And it wasn’t just the Opposition.

READ ALSO Watch out, time of use and peak demand billing have some serious pitfalls

Labor’s once-rusted-on partners in government, the Greens, had a crack at the government for being so tardy with the light rail rollout, saying it wasn’t giving enough priority to the project.

Last week, the Public Transport Association was also nipping at the government’s heels over a lack of pre-planning for extending light rail and calling for concurrent work on different stages to ensure a smoother and speedier construction program.

In its budget submission, PTCBR also called for a number of improvements to the bus network, including priority signalling, connections and timetabling, many of which the Liberals have taken on board.

Despite Ms Cheyne and Mr Steel’s office doing their best to counter these assaults, it will be up to the Transport Minister to grab the public’s attention and again put the case for a light rail network, explain why buses alone can’t be the solution to Canberra’s future public transport needs and why all of this can’t be done tomorrow.

The pushing back of the light rail schedule for stage 2A and the much more challenging 2B has given the Liberals an opening to undermine the project’s viability. They have also stoked fear about the cost, now saying it’s $4 billion-plus for both legs.

Mr Steel will have all of the advantages of incumbency and the bureaucracy at his disposal to tackle the Liberals head-on and pick apart its policy.

But he will need to do more than just rebut claims. Mr Steel will have to rekindle people’s capacity for long-term planning and take another can of polish to the light rail project.

Despite the Liberals now questioning whether even stage 1 is that successful, there are still plenty of Canberrans who want a line like the Gungahlin-City route to come to their neck of the woods.

Just a bit sooner.

READ ALSO Public sector boom equals good times ahead for ACT economy, says business outlook

Mr Steel will also have to tidy up the bus network and deliver the new ticketing system.

There are more than five months to go before polling day, so there is still plenty of time for Labor to roll out its own public transport policy full of shiny baubles. The immediate challenge is to seize back the initiative.

He will have to paint the Opposition’s policy as short-sighted and opportunistic and his own as a visionary plan in the city’s long-term interests.

In an environment of lengthening timelines, rising costs, budget pressures and decreasing attention spans, that will be no easy task.

Join the conversation

15
All Comments
  • All Comments
  • Website Comments
LatestOldest

didn’t even know he was on leave and now that he is back, will anything be different?

ChrisinTurner8:19 pm 30 Apr 24

What is needed is a statement on the subsidy per passenger for the existing buses, the Light Rail Stage 1 and Light rail Stage 2. Are they really $6, $15 and $25?

HiddenDragon7:56 pm 29 Apr 24

The light rail “vision” as it has thus far been sold to the ACT public is a mirage, based on highly unrealistic expectations about what can be done and when it can be done – but it has been a wonderful gimmick and distraction for a very ordinary government which has succumbed to the temptation of telling many Canberrans what they wanted to hear.

The best thing that Chris Steel could do would be to put his big boy pants on (with, of course, the permission of the Puppet Master-in-Chief) and deliver some home truths to Canberrans about a truly realistic timetable for light rail and honest estimates of the costs to an already stretched ACT budget.

If the Greens, and others, think it can be done and afforded somewhat more quickly, let them explain exactly how that would work.

Steele has exceeded his level of competence. As a taxpayer I’m sick to death of forking out good money to have it wasted by someone who clearly failed scribbling in Kindy.

Best comment I’ve read in a long time. Love it.

Whatever you think of a Minister, this is literally a childish argument, and unkind. You have an opinion about light rail, fair enough, I don’t agree with you but I respect you have that view, but attacking someone ignores what it can cost them, and makes good people wary of entering politics.

Steel can’t properly manage a single CIT executive or a $76 million dollar payroll system, I have little faith he can properly manage a multi billion dollar light rail project, with so many competing stakeholders, challenging financial returns and our city’s competition for appropriately skilled workers.

He’s very skilled in using words in the media to sound like he’s on top of things and he’s great at cherry picking some statistics to support his views, BUT he’s actual track record as a Minister in delivering real outcomes is abysmal. He’s possibly the worst minister ACT self government has ever seen (and there were some doozies in earlier local governments).

“The pushing back of the light rail schedule for stage 2A and the much more challenging 2B has given the Liberals an opening to undermine the project’s viability. They have also stoked fear about the cost, now saying it’s $4 billion-plus for both legs.”

Easy solution: Release a detailed and up to date business case with costings to prove the viability of 2B… but we all know they won’t do that because IF it exists, it wouldn’t make for flattering reading.

“Labor’s once-rusted-on partners in government, the Greens, had a crack at the government for being so tardy with the light rail rollout, saying it wasn’t giving enough priority to the project.”

3 Greens sit in the cabinet and are part of the government decisions on public transport, then they send out one of the 3 Greens who sit on the cross-bench to complain about those same government decisions. Greens are playing both political sides, at the same time, and so far the voters are letting them get away with it.

You’ve got to laugh when all this article talks about is political angling and spin for the government to “regain the initiative”.

When all Steele should really have to do is point to the detailed studies and reports that have been commissioned and released to the public outlining the transport needs, assessed options and the cost/benefit ratios of moving forward with a preferred solution.

Hmmm, it’s almost like the evidence in support of light rail for Canberra doesn’t actually exist.

“Mr Steel will also have to tidy up the bus network and deliver the new ticketing system” ha ha ha ha, that’s funny. Just put him back on leave where he can’t break anything or waste any more taxpayers money, the guy is useless and will only create more mess.

Daily Digest

Want the best Canberra news delivered daily? Every day we package the most popular Riotact stories and send them straight to your inbox. Sign-up now for trusted local news that will never be behind a paywall.

By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.