21 November 2024

Shadow cabinet will struggle without experienced players

| Ian Bushnell
Join the conversation
57
Mark Parton and Elizabeth Lee

On the outer: Mark Parton and Elizabeth Lee are notably absent from the shadow cabinet. Photo: Ian Bushnell.

It doesn’t say much for the Canberra Liberals that a former leader and arguably its best communicator don’t want to serve in Leanne Castley’s shadow cabinet.

Elizabeth Lee’s pre-election brain snap didn’t help, but the election loss was not all on her.

Similarly, Mark Parton shouldn’t be reduced to putting his skills to use presiding over question time instead of being in the thick of the cut and thrust.

On the morning of the snap bus strike, it was Mr Parton who turned up on ABC radio cutting through, not Ms Castley, who also happens to be the new transport spokesperson.

READ ALSO Rudd insists he’s ready to work closely with the new Trump administration

In such a small party room, the Opposition simply can’t afford to lose two of its most experienced people because of ongoing factional or personality differences.

At least Ms Castley says the door remains open to Ms Lee, but the feeling is the former leader may be looking elsewhere.

Mr Parton has cross-party appeal, is an accomplished media performer and is popular. With a bit more application, he would be an effective leader, but either he doesn’t want it or, for some reason, can’t muster the support needed.

But he should still be in the shadow cabinet.

Without these two, Ms Castley had to turn to new members Deborah Morris and Chiaka Barry to take on multiple portfolios, and relative newcomer Ed Cocks to carry the important Treasury portfolio.

She insists that they have the life experience to see them through, but she struggled to detail that, and they will face a steep learning curve.

Perhaps too steep to worry Labor this term.

Liberal leader Leanne Castley with her deputy Jeremy Hanson. She will need his experience. Photo: Ian Bushnell.

While Ms Castley has grown through her first term and has good interpersonal skills, much of the Opposition burden will fall to the experienced right-wing warrior Jeremy Hanson, who should have remained on the front bench under Ms Lee.

He curiously will only have Education, where he can claim some credit for the current reforms, and Veterans on his plate.

Will he be pragmatic Jeremy or revert to prosecuting causes about which that the electorate has made clear its position?

This is a conservative shadow cabinet and the perception problem still haunts the Liberals in progressive Canberra, especially with two moderates now on the outer.

Ms Castley’s eschewing of ideological positions to focus on basic services is a good start. Interestingly, Labor’s takeout from the election is similar.

But big policy positions such as light rail await. On that issue, the Liberals need to move on because there have been enough elections fought about it.

The promised “warts and all” review of the campaign will set the tone for term, but there are some in the party already writing off 2028 and looking wistfully to 2032.

A lot can happen quickly in politics, incumbency is becoming increasingly fragile and governments can easily stuff things up, but budging Labor could be an even tougher job in 2028 than 2024.

The inexperienced Opposition will take time to have any real impact while a chastened Labor seems determined to deliver and marshal the bureaucracy.

By 2028, several major capital works will be complete or near completion – the Northside Hospital, the Lyric Theatre, and Light Rail Stage 2A.

Approvals should be in place for Light Rail Stage 2B – even a Coalition government should see the need for it to service growing Barton – and a contract in sight.

There should also be starts on the new Bruce stadium and the convention centre and entertainment pavilion in the city, as well as a new aquatic centre in Commonwealth Park and a new public park at the Acton Waterfront.

As well as these big set pieces, expect to see smaller community projects across the ACT, but particularly in the south where the swing against Labor was most pronounced.

READ ALSO ACT wins extra $35 million in schools funding deal

The electrification of the bus fleet will be well on the way.

The Strong Foundation reforms in ACT schools should also be making an impact on student performance.

There should be a surge in housing supply thanks to accelerated land releases and federal money.

That may sound like a Labor manifesto but with so much going on, it will be challenging for the Liberals to make a case for change.

Of course, there is also the capacity for project delay and failure, budget blowouts, faltering school reforms and housing mirages.

The question is, will this depleted, or at least underdone Opposition be up to seizing the opportunities that arise?

Join the conversation

57
All Comments
  • All Comments
  • Website Comments
LatestOldest

It is debatable whether Mark Parton is particularly talented as an MLA but he does entertain. He is without doubt the opposition’s best performer, particularly in the media and is popular within his community.

This is without doubt the most conservative lineup of Liberals ever seen elected to the Assembly. It is scary to see who were given the shadow roles of Attorney General and Women portfolios, but there is not much to choose from. Mr Parton and Elizabeth Lee are the only, and most moderate of those elected. It will be interesting to watch what Ms Lee with her skills will do in the future and whether she will step down. She is definitely the most able and professionally qualified on the opposition benches. Who would want to stick around for the next four years in opposition with this mob!

The snap bus strike was an opportunity for Leanne Castley to step forward in her new role as leader and hold the government to account. Unfortunately, she was too inept to see the opportunity which has now passed. Jeremy Hanson is only intent on the leadership role so he will not be offering any support, continuing his efforts in backstabbing, undermining and wrecking the party.

One hopes Mr Hanson is wearing his elevator shoes, he is such a little man!

Mr Parton now has the speakership role to keep him busy and hopefully out of trouble. It is more than likely that he turned down a shadow ministry role and no one could blame him. Unfortunately this paved the way for the sluggish James Milligan to take over the shadow sport and recreation ministry, giving him a few more freebies. We can now look forward to more of Mr Milligan, sticking his goofy head up at sporting events around Canberra!

Parton will be biding his time for Castley to lose the next election. He wouldn’t be stupid enough to have Hansen on the front bench let alone deputy.

Maybe it is wishful thinking on your part Elf but it is hard for me to imagine Mark Parton ever “biding his time” to lead the rabble that is the Canberra Liberals! The party has been in opposition for 23 years and its current MLA’s are the most conservative ever elected to the Assembly in its history.

Andrew Barr gave Mark Parton an escape route with the role of Speaker. I have no doubts Mr Parton is aware of this and thankful.

Could anyone imagine how mind numbing it would be wasting away in opposition for another four years in that snake pit that is the Canberra Liberals?

The party is a party going backwards and that is evidenced by the results from the past three elections and and their current leadership team!

why can’t this author move on from the liberals, which he clearly doesn’t like? it’s been a month since the election and several weeks since the new liberal leadership took over. time to move on Ian as nothing is going to change with the liberal party in the foreseeable future.

meanwhile, where are your objective articles on the Govt? oh that’s right, there will only be “positive puff pieces”

How can the Liberal party move on from light rail when it’s a budget killer the ACT can’t afford? The cost benefit analysis of stage 1 by the ACTPS and all the unpaid expert commentary from interstate clearly showed it was a bad investment, coming with high costs and low value compared to BRT. Then there’s also the opportunity cost, which was the new hospital promised by Gallagher. We’ve only just started drawing up plans to build it more than a decade after the original plans were scrapped. The rehab hospital and walk-in clinics have been a poor substitute and the health of Canberrans dependent on the public health system has suffered.

The Liberals wouldn’t be doing the right thing by the electorate to support it in the hope it would give a populist boost to their vote. If some in the electorate want to use their personal anecdotal experiences or emotions about light rail as an excuse not to vote Liberal rather than looking at the expert analysis, that’s on them.

Also, if people look at Labor’s repeated delays on stage 2, it’s clear they know it’s unaffordable. Rather than being honest with the electorate, they just keep pushing the timeline out so they can keep the votes of the people who support it without understanding the increasingly negative impact it will have on the average Canberran’s quality of life.

Yes,
You have to laugh at the author’s puff piece on the government’s spending priorities when even by their own generous assumptions in the budget the debt is ballooning unsustainably.

As you say, it’s the actual reason why all of their election promises keep being delayed over and over again.

HiddenDragon8:52 pm 22 Nov 24

With Labor now governing in minority, it will be easier for the non-Labor MLAs to hold the executive government and its bureaucracy to higher standards of accountability than we have seen for many years – if ever – in the era of self-government in the ACT.

This presents real opportunities for the Liberals (and the Greens and Independents) not just to highlight Labor’s failures and shortcomings, but also to get better results for Canberrans.

With hard work and persistence, even a relatively inexperienced Opposition could utilise these opportunities to make a difference of the sort which will truly be noticed by 2028.

GrumpyGrandpa5:52 pm 22 Nov 24

I was a bit on the fence about Ms Lee’s ability to forcely take on the government, and sell the Opposition’s position to the media.
I agree that having Ms Lee and Mr Parton in active roles in the Opposition, best utilises their skills and serves the community, but the role of Speaker for Mr Parton, what a great result for the government! One of the Opposition’s better performers now neutralised.
Yeah, I think the Opposition have lost some front bench talent.

I hardly say that Labor have a switched on team, neither side know what they are doing.

Lee now demonstrates that she was never part of the Liberals in the ACT. It was well-known and predicted that the ACT Liberals could not win the election under Lee. The ‘Lee middle finger’ is no longer wanted by the party and the electorate..

You can’t blame her for their previous losses. The fact is, ACT Liberals are unelectable at the moment. They need a good clean out of the men in grey suits lurking in the background.

They won’t do it Megsy.

Just looking at the unhinged nature of the rhetoric from the Liberal boosters…they’re not about to try to meet the electorate in the middle.

The fact that Lee is not as far right as them makes her “never part of the Liberals in the ACT”…they’re not going to change….they’re going to spend the next four years on this blog and the Canberra Times spitting spite and venom at anyone who doesn’t subscribe to their far right-wing, post-truth group think….including people on their own side of politics and then they’ll wonder why Labor is forming government yet again.

The quality of candidates provided by the Liberals is marginally worse than Labor and that takes some doing.

Ian De Landelles2:59 pm 22 Nov 24

Politics always has, and always will be, the art of the possible. As Albert Einstein famously said, ‘Insanity is doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results’.

Yet this is exactly what the Canberras Liberals have been doing since their election loss in 2000, resulting in seven consecutive election losses, and a senate seat to boot.

Political tragics of my vintage will recall it took federal intervention into the Victorian branch of the ALP to remove George Crawford, Bill Hartley and co, resulting in Gough Whitlam’s 1972 victory.

If ACT Labor had ‘achieved’ the same results as there Liberal counterparts, the Federal Executive would have intervened years ago.

Never a better observation comrade

The only good thing about the Liberal shadow cabinet is at least they’ve given up the pretence that they’re moderate.

Of course, they’re going to lose again, they can’t expect to be anti-public transport, anti-climate, anti-LGBT, anti-women’s rights, anti-VAD in this region and expect to do well but at least they’ve given up the attempt to con the electorate into believing they’re something that they’re not.

You could sum all that up with “The ACT Liberals are anti-crackpot”.

Well, you could if you were clueless or living in an alternate universe to the rest of us, and/or if you wanted the ACT Liberals to continue losing elections in the ACT.

So women’s rights are ‘crackpot’ are they now and public transport is ‘crackpot’….

Sure thing.

Anti Women’s rights? The last 2 leaders have been women you goose. Trying hard to colour them as Zed devotees shows the desperation of you rusted in Labor dopes!

“Anti Women’s rights? The last 2 leaders have been women you goose. ” I don’t know how you’re name calling with an argument that dumb….it’s the equivalent of “I can’t be sexist, my wife is a woman”.

Having women leaders hasn’t stopped the Liberals from voting against abortion access for example.

Sorry facts getting in the way again. Maybe before slinging insults in future, think.

PS. I like the way you’re calling people rusted on Labor (because everyone who isn’t on the extreme right where you lot sit must by definition be Labor….or Greens…or whatever) meanwhile Russian apologist Ken, directly above calls women’s rights a “crackpot” issue.

Do you have any names for Ken? You know because the ACT Liberals and their boosters are super keen on women’s rights…they even know a few…apparently.

You know what you can do with your sad little insults champ.

Daily Digest

Want the best Canberra news delivered daily? Every day we package the most popular Riotact stories and send them straight to your inbox. Sign-up now for trusted local news that will never be behind a paywall.

By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.