Too much tucker in Canberra restaurants?

johnboy 22 September 2008 25

The Herald Sun’s Chris Wallace has found an un-named restaurant critic to slag off Canberra restaurants in comparison with the glories of Melbourne:

    A national restaurant critic has just marked Canberra restaurants down for not quite meeting Melbourne’s pre-eminent standard. Serving size was the damning evidence.

    Every food snob knows the implicit fine dining equation: small serves signal high quality. Too much was slapped on the plate in even the best national capital restaurants, the critic said, for Canberra cuisine to be taken seriously.

Your thoughts?


What's Your Opinion?


Please login to post your comments, or connect with
25 Responses to Too much tucker in Canberra restaurants?
Filter
Order
sprintman sprintman 5:15 pm 03 Nov 08

To many restaurants in Canberra and way to many serving cr@p. Yes Melbourne dining is far better than Canberra, that’s becuae the locals won’t patronise places that don’t make the grade, unlike Canberrans who think if it’s edible it’s acceptable. Not sure how you fix that though?

imarty imarty 8:58 pm 22 Sep 08

WTF??? Makes a Today Tonight segue look smooth as a freshly licked plate from Central Cafe.
For what its worth, in my experience size is irrelevant, quality of the produce is number one, what the chef does (or doesn’t do) with it is number two.
Many here seem to be well travelled and I’m sure that many have had amazing meals that cost F all but were prepared simply and with care.

BerraBoy68 BerraBoy68 8:55 pm 22 Sep 08

What a knob. Where’s the culinary delight in paying $100 for a meal and going home hungry?

Pile it up I say…

ant ant 8:19 pm 22 Sep 08

Thank god that food critic didn’t visit the eateries of Queanbeyan. He’d have died in horror. They have to put the food in layers, as it won’t all fit on the plate otherwise. To get the chips you have to burrow under the schnitzel.

Loquaciousness Loquaciousness 7:27 pm 22 Sep 08

astrojax said :

if any restaurant ‘critic’ measures the quality of the establishment by the serve size, then they should f*** up and die and immediately drop such an outlandish sobriquet.

Hear! Hear!

L

astrojax astrojax 7:12 pm 22 Sep 08

Melbourne dining is … lightyears away from Canberra

actually, ‘s only about 650kms… ; )

if any restaurant ‘critic’ measures the quality of the establishment by the serve size, then they should f*** up and die and immediately drop such an outlandish sobriquet.

rosie_bubz rosie_bubz 6:41 pm 22 Sep 08

there are plenty of restuarants around canebrra where u can go to get a plate piled up with food, and there are plenty that give way smaller portions.
it just depends what u feel like….

i myself prefer the piled up option… Some for now, take some home for later 🙂

Duke Duke 4:51 pm 22 Sep 08

I think portion sizes here in Canberra are spot-on, as are price and quality, on the whole. We’ve discussed this before, that because Canberra has a relatively small population the bad restaurants tend to get squeezed out pretty quick.

We did however eat at an expensive, well known, award winning Italian restaurant in Civic some weeks back and the mains, though delicious, were so small some of us headed straight for Ali Baba afterwards. I can assure you the bill for 6 people was far from entree sized.

jakez jakez 4:07 pm 22 Sep 08

There’s nothing I hate more than those ridiculously small serving sizes you get at self styled ‘fancy’ restaurants.

‘oh look, there’s a steak under those two pieces of brussel sprout that I just ate.’

johnboy johnboy 3:36 pm 22 Sep 08

My 2c is it all depends on how you’re ordering.

If you’re having bread, entree, main, side dishes, desert, chocolate with coffee, along with beer for starters, wine with the meal, and licquer with the coffee, then I know I don’t have room for huge portions anywhere along the way.

If I’m just having one plate on the other hand, it had better be full to the edges.

tylersmayhem tylersmayhem 3:31 pm 22 Sep 08

@Loquaciousness: I agree 100%!

Loquaciousness Loquaciousness 2:55 pm 22 Sep 08

I’ve said it before on RA, and I’ll say it again – I’m a big fan of tasty, quality, well-prepared food. The Melbournites can keep their stack-and-drizzle little things any day. I want to eat it not take a photo of it.

L

caf caf 2:46 pm 22 Sep 08

Primal, for some people the primary role of a restaurant is to provide an experience that they enjoy. For such people, spending $300 on a small-but-perfectly-formed restaurant meal is no different to others spending a similar amount on, say, Formula 1 tickets, or a night at the theatre. It’s about the experience rather than the calories – if you’re going to a fine dining restaurant purely for the nutrients, then I dare say you’re missing the point.

Primal Primal 2:39 pm 22 Sep 08

The primary role of a restaurant is to fill my stomach. When you do not understand this, you should stop trying to be a restaurant critic.

justbands justbands 11:03 am 22 Sep 08

> Canberra dining is utter, utter rubbish

I’m guessing you’re eating in the wrong places. I’ve had better meals here than anywhere. I’m more of the opinion that individual restaurants are different, rather than “Melbourne good, Sydney bad” generalisations. Would a great chef from Melbourne who moved to Canberra suddenly start cooking crap food?

Whatsup Whatsup 10:59 am 22 Sep 08

If that was the worst thing he could complain about then that is a real credit to our local restaurants. Take it as a compliment ! He clearly had to find something negative to appease the Melbourne readers.

cmdwedge cmdwedge 10:59 am 22 Sep 08

Canberra dining is utter, utter rubbish. That we put up with such substandard food, drinks and service is beyond me.

Melbourne dining is miles ahead of Sydney, and lightyears away from Canberra.

Stop putting up with rubbish, fellow Canberrans!

gun street girl gun street girl 10:42 am 22 Sep 08

Similarly, everybody knows that real journalists don’t write for the Herald Sun. What next – an expose of Canberra restaurants on Today Tonight?

Granny Granny 10:35 am 22 Sep 08

C’mon people, everybody knows that a true celebrity would never deign to eat more than one artistically placed lettuce leaf ….

When it comes to food, Canberra just can’t cut the mustard.

Spectra Spectra 10:28 am 22 Sep 08

Wankers. If you’re going to judge food quality based on inverse serving size, I would submit that you’ve missed the point. That’s like judging wine by its price (in which case I’ve got some extremely expensive wine to sell you at a generous discount). How about judging it by…say…it’s taste and presentation? Or is that getting too complex? Is all that’s required to be a food critic these days a set of scales and a ruler?

CBR Tweets

Sign up to our newsletter

 Top
Region Group Pty Ltd

Search across the site