11 November 2024

Supermarket shows public can fight back against self-service checkout machines

| Oliver Jacques
Join the conversation
41
two women standing at supermarket checkout

Rossies staff Cheryl Mott and Elena Conte have been familiar faces at the FoodWorks store in Griffith NSW for years and are much-loved by their customers. Photos: Oliver Jacques.

Are supermarket self-service machines an inevitable consequence of technological progress?

Much like social media companies collecting and using our personal data to enrich themselves, it’s something the masses have lazily come to accept.

But the overwhelming response to Region’s article about the success of Rossies FoodWorks – the last bastion of human-only service at a major grocery store in Griffith NSW – shows we can fight back against an unpopular trend.

READ ALSO If self-checkouts are on their way out, it’s time to embrace incidental human interaction

The Facebook post on why Rossies has resisted automation was shared over 100 times and received more than 2000 likes across multiple pages.

Our poll on Region Riverina revealed 70 per cent of respondents “despise” automated checkout machines and a further 24 per cent tolerate them but prefer face-to-face service.

So why have we allowed Coles and Woolworths to gradually replace checkout chicks and dudes with unwieldy machines that turn customers into unpaid labourers for companies that make billion-dollar-plus profits every year?

We can vote with our feet and send a message to these corporations, by shopping at pro-human supermarkets, even if we might have to pay a tad more for some items.

If we must shop at the big chains, we can line up and wait for available humans instead of going to the automated sections. We can also write to these companies and tell them what we think.

customer buying groceries

Customer Alo Pologa enjoys being served by staff such as Abbie Hardwick.

Rebelling against self-service has made an impact in other countries.

In the United States, Walmart withdrew self-checkout lanes from three stores in the state of New Mexico earlier this year.

In Britain, supermarket chain Booths recently removed automated kiosks in all but two of its 28 stores.

Booths managing director Nigel Murray told the BBC that people had said the machines were slow, unreliable and impersonal.

He added customers were frequently misidentifying fruits and vegetables.

And why wouldn’t they? I can’t tell the difference between a Pink Lady and a Royal Gala apple. It’s not my job. These companies ought to be paying people to do that for us.

READ ALSO Local apprentice gets on the tools at Supercheap Auto Bathurst International event

Supermarkets are a valuable source of employment in small towns. As so many blue-collar jobs disappear due to automation, we can’t afford to write off checkout staff.

While some people see working at a grocery store as a transient job for young people, Rossies has had employees who have been there for decades.

The manager, Ross Catanzariti, got his start packing groceries as a 12-year-old back in the 1960s. He’s now one of the most influential people in town.

“We are like a family here,” Rossies staffer Cheryl Mott says. That’s why people like to shop there, to see those familiar faces.”

Griffith’s Coles and Woolworths stores also have some wonderful, loyal, long-term staff.

Nationwide, Woolworths made a $1.6 billion profit last year, while Coles raked in $1.1 billion. There’s no reason for them to lay off more employees. And as paying customers, we shouldn’t let them.

Original Article published by Oliver Jacques on Region Riverina.

Join the conversation

41
All Comments
  • All Comments
  • Website Comments
LatestOldest
Julian Randall11:43 pm 28 Jan 24

Much prefer self checkout. Based on the amount of people I see using it instead of lining up for a checkout person so do they. Sucks people are going to lose their jobs but it’s really a luddite way of thinking trying to keep these jobs.

Most of the time I choose the self serve checkout.

IR laws and regulations that supposedly protect workers only make it harder to employ people. It’s much easier to service a machine. That is the driver.

As someone who sufferes social anxiety self service checkouts are the only way i will shop. I dont want to speak to anyone and have some checkout person speak to me.
I can also pack much faster then someone who talks or looks around the shop while slowly packing my stuff.

Bunnings is the one that gets me. Plenty of self service checkouts rarely opened. It’s like they want you to wait in a queue.

Peter Thorburn1:56 pm 21 Jan 24

Self serve checkouts are better in pretty much every situation, and are faster and more convenient (although you don’t get to feel superior to a staff member so I guess that’s a problem). Nobody is being fired by Coles or Woolies because of them; both have hired more people in recent years, but they’re just doing actually useful jobs now. It’s fine to keep one served aisle for the people who are either too old or incompetent, while the rest of us with basic life skills breeze through ten times faster.

I’m actually more likely to avoid a supermarket that only has, say, three checkout lanes, albeit human operated, than one that has twelve, albeit machine operated. Reason is through-rate: I wanna get out of there, not wait in a long queue. Surely a mix is best, and that’s what the supermarkets I go to already have — you choose person or machine. So this is a non problem.

Meanwhile, basic health and education in our nearest neighbouring countries are really inadequate. Just saying.

These large supermarkets take us for mugs and we go along with it. Customers at the supermarkets in Canberra I have noticed seem to have a preference for self service. I refuse to use the self serve. If the supermarkets want me to serve myself they can give me a discount!

Aldi has just introduced self-serve and have checkout operators manning both counter and those serving themselves. It is a total time waster with limited staff flitting between both.

Not to mention those loyalty cards where customers have provided all of their personal information and the supermarkets know everything about their buying habits!

So, Jack D, where do you go to buy fuel for your car? I can’t think of a petrol station in Canberra where someone comes out and pumps it for you. Of course you may have an EV which would make this question redundant.

And when you are in the supermarket do you go around the shop picking up the items you want for yourself, or do you go to some old fashioned place where the grocer gets everything for you from the shelves behind the counter?

I really don’t see the difference between these two scenarios and scanning your items at the checkout.

Peter Thorburn1:57 pm 21 Jan 24

“If the supermarkets want me to serve myself they can give me a discount!”

Literally the most boomer comment imaginable.

GrumpyGrandpa9:26 pm 21 Jan 24

Hi Jack D.
If you will only use a human checkout, I respect that, but for me, I go to which ever I think will be quicker.

Even Costco has the option of self-checkouts and if you only have a few items, believe me, their self-checkouts are a lot quicker than waiting in a long line of people with their full king-sized trolleys.

I note that you are opposed Loyalty cards such as Flybuys and Woolworths Rewards cards. Sure, they collect data, so does Microsoft, Google, Apple, Amazon and Facebook.

I have only been to Costco once GG. We don’t need to buy bulk except for “Don’t give a crap”. I can highly recommend it. They notify us every 3 months and the goods arrive automatically within 2 days if we don’t respond.

I don’t have a Microsoft, Google, Apple, Amazon and Facebook account.

Daily Digest

Want the best Canberra news delivered daily? Every day we package the most popular Riotact stories and send them straight to your inbox. Sign-up now for trusted local news that will never be behind a paywall.

By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.