19 December 2024

Brindabella Christian College staff call on board to resign

| Ian Bushnell
Join the conversation
15
Brindabella Christian College

Brindabella Christian College is facing a staff exodus as it waits on a decision about its future. Photo: Michelle Kroll

Staff at the troubled Brindabella Christian College have called on all board members of the private Lyneham-based school to resign as dozens of their colleagues vote with their feet ahead of an imminent decision on its future from ACT Education Minister Yvette Berry.

The staff, all Independent Education Union members, wrote to the board of Brindabella Christian Education Ltd last week saying it had habitually failed to meet its financial obligations and that the antagonistic leadership of chair Greg Zwajgenberg was driving staff away from the school and alienating the school community.

The school reform group, Reform BCC, backed the staff members and also called for regulatory intervention to prevent directors from having access to school funds in order to safeguard students’ education in 2025.

READ ALSO Universities lay out the election policies they want to see from both sides

The letter said there had been an alarming number of resignations, and it is understood that more than 30 and possibly 40 staff had handed in their notices.

The school website lists 20 vacancy notices across teaching and non-teaching staff, with some for multiple casual teacher roles.

“Therefore, at this time, we seek the immediate resignation of current board members and that constitutional changes are made to allow a new governance structure to be implemented, in consultation with government entities and the college community,” the letter said.

Ms Berry is expected to announce before Christmas what regulatory action will be taken, if any, against the school over ongoing governance and financial breaches. The school could lose its registration and funding, although this is unlikely given it has more than 1200 students enrolled.

In September, she demanded BCEL show proof of the school’s financial viability and governance standards.

The Registrar and Registration Standards Advisory Board has been weighing BCEL’s response and liaising with the Australian Government, which provides $10 million a year in funding.

The letter said staff entitlements such as superannuation had not been paid on time, leave had been incorrectly calculated, and salaries had been paid late. It is understood that the September quarter super payment, due on 28 September, was not paid until 4 December.

The school also was an outlier in negotiations over a new pay agreement. Unlike other Christian schools, it did not provide an interim pay increase and kept staff in the dark about the progress of the talks.

“The actions of the BCEL board have directly contributed to the alarming number of resignations we are seeing in our college, further impacting our financial and educational viability and burdening staff wellbeing,” the letter said.

“This is not symptomatic of disloyalty; they are valued colleagues many of whom are frustrated by the financial uncertainty and the hostile tone exhibited when concerns are raised.”

The letter said staff “strongly object” to board members’ claims that the media attention, litigation and community concern were “the result of a ‘culture war’ aimed at Christianity in general, and Brindabella Christian College in particular”.

“It is precisely this antagonistic and dismissive attitude, under the leadership of Greg Zwajgenberg, which has fuelled negativity and the breakdown of relationships within and beyond the college community, leading to increased economic and psychosocial pressures on staff,” the letter said.

Last week, Mr Zwajgenberg alleged on social media a four-year vendetta against the school fuelled by people with personal agendas. He attacked Ms Berry for allegedly lying about working with the school through its issues and making statements in the media without talking to the school first.

He said the school was a victim of its own success and it had complied with every requirement, only to have these actions “weaponised” against it.

READ ALSO Gaining experience, building connections, finding treasures: the life of a Vinnies summer volunteer

The school’s reform group wrote to Ms Berry last week, saying it was increasingly concerned about Mr Zwajgenberg’s persecutory rhetoric, which failed to address governance and financial issues.

“We are concerned that his ongoing messaging and disinformation campaign may further negatively affect the viability of the school as well as the wellbeing of students, parents and staff at BCC,” Reform BCC said.

Today (18 December), Reform BCC released a statement saying it supported the staff members’ call for the immediate removal of all current board members and constitutional reform.

“Without these measures, we believe the school is no longer viable,” it said.

“Our community association commends the bravery of teachers and staff in speaking out despite the personal risks they face. Their stand against a long-standing governance culture that has failed to provide a safe and secure environment for staff and families highlights the urgent need for change.

“To safeguard students’ education next year, we urge a ban on directors’ access to school funds and immediate intervention from regulatory and oversight bodies, including the ACNC [the Australian Charities and Not-for-profits Commission], ATO, ASIC, the school’s lender, the NAB, and education authorities.”

The school has announced a new principal to replace Keturah Jones, who left in August. He is Peter Reuben, who was previously been District Principal of One School Global Australia, a school system established by members of the Plymouth Brethren Christian Church, previously known as the Exclusive Brethren.

Mr Reuben also taught and was registrar at the King’s School in Parramatta for more than 13 years.

Comment was sought from Mr Zwajgenberg, but he only provided an off-the-record response.

Join the conversation

15
All Comments
  • All Comments
  • Website Comments
LatestOldest

This is a typical tactic where a “private” school is admonished for poor performances. blame it on people attacking the religion or the ethics of the school.
“the result of a ‘culture war’ aimed at Christianity in general, and Brindabella Christian College in particular”.
All employers must realise that loyalty is a two way street.
I taught in Non-Government Schools for nearly 30 years. It was a job I loved and was always loyal to the schools.
I also was a founding member of the first Union for ACT staff in these schools, not out of disloyalty but out of a sense of equity.
I have seen the best and worst of “private” schools but most are good.
From time to time, as in any industry, there are going to be disputes and this is not an attack on the religion or the ethics of that religion.

That is his view. Let the process run. I believe there are actions that can be taken to course correct, including punitive ones. One cannot help but wonder whether indeed this is persecution of the christians….noting that they aren’t perfect (the christians)

Looking forward to having a great multifunction arts centre in Lyneham once BCC vacates, lol

I am not sure your dream will come true … LoL

Bigger your idiocy the safer you are
“The school could lose its registration and funding, although this is unlikely given it has more than 1200 students enrolled.”

So tired of these articles! Don’t you have anything else to write about? This concerted effort on this school is beyond anything. Every month, there are more than 2 articles repeating the same claims, even when there are known on going processes to deal with the said issues. What you gain out of these articles is beyond my understanding.

I am so tired of Brindabella Christian College flouting laws and breaching government regulations with questions around its reporting and financial viability being raised by the public and in the media over a number of years. In 2021 the federal Minister for Education found that the school’s governing body, Brindabella Christian Education Limited was not a “fit and proper person” to operate the school. The school was behind in its financial reporting, with mandatory reports not submitted to federal and territory government authorities, including the taxation office on time. The school has been under investigations by both governments for its lack of compliance since then.

The school receives $10 million dollars in public funding each year. In 2022 it was reported that the school was $4.8 million in debt, including unpaid wages and superannuation contributions to staff. Infrastructure projects including a carpark and demountable buildings were also being constructed without approval, haphazardly on school grounds and public land, with a makeshift crossing erected at the entrance posing safety risks to pedestrians and children. Court action was also in progress due to the school’s non-compliance which BCC subsequently lost.

Shamefully, and noticeably the responsible ACT education minister Yvette Berry, in a Labor government which supposedly represents workers rights, the Fair Work Ombudsman, the Australian Taxation Office, the Children’s Education and Care Services regulator and others have been silent in advocating and representing the families and teachers at the school throughout this time.

With the schools future uncertain and only six days until Christmas I sympathise and wonder how the staff, students and parents of the children are feeling.

May you have a joyous and merry Christmas Bragaba!

Finance 6'5" Blue Eyes11:14 am 19 Dec 24

Eye opening indeed; our media providing information on the corruption in our schools in the ACT is critical to keep it in the public eye and monitor the resolution that is formed.
Brindabella has a lot of fixing to do, and a lot to answer to; I’m sure a lackluster apology will be distributed in 2025.

I’m still amazed they bought a $100k robot, whilst at the same time not paying their staff; what a way to rub salt in the wound for the staff! Also worth noting the amount of money they spend on marketing and advertising as well, I’m sure the teachers would rather get paid than see another Canberra bus painted in full Brindabella decals.

Alleged breaking of rules! In some cases, rules have been broken and corrective actions including punitive ones have been taken, but I am questioning the continued reporting and rehashing of all the claims. It is a concerted effort feom this publication. It seems to me that are all the claims here? If they are and the regulators haven’t done anything about them for a decade, what is the chance that they will now? Am tempted to think most of this is a smear that won’t turn into anything tangible save the distress caused to students and parents. Most commentary referencing reform BCC also creates the impression that there is a power struggle with every thing thrown at the school to kick out whoever is running it. Whatever it is, I am over the reporting which rehashes every issue even those that have been resolved.

If you’re tired of the articles Bragaba, don’t read them.

Personally, I’m keen to be updated on the behaviour of those running this school, having some expertise in organisational misbehaviour. The actions reported here are beyond the pale and all the more shocking because there are more issues over time and they are still unresolved.

I don’t understand the failure to pull this organisation into line with the law or to close it down if they continue to behave badly. There are new acts of abuse and mistreatment of individuals and communities in each article I read. As a taxpayer I resent my taxes being used to support such an organisation that has so little regard for those they harm.

Bragaba you clearly don’t understand journalism. When a new issue occurs in an ongoing organisation, it is normal to provide some background to the organisation and the issue as this context is essential to proper understanding. If you don’t like it, don’t read it. Stop whingeing about it.

Reform BCC was started by former BCC Staff, Principals, parents and former students, who have been and still are, calling for exactly what the current BCC staff are demanding. This has been going on since 2011. Would a government agency please step up and stop this insanity and corruption?!?

If it started in 2011 yet its continued activity hasn’t led to change, what is the chance that anything will come out of this? The government agencies you are calling upon I speculate here, know that they have no authority or legal basis to do anything. Alternatively they are incompetent or complicit.
In the end the parents, staff and students suffer.
I can’t help but think that the governance issues are being used as a scape goat for other agenda including closing the school because of proclaiming christianity, its showcasing of the innovation etc.
I also speculate that not all the things being highlighted as issues are illegal even though they may seem wrong.
The outrage over 10M in my view is over the top considering all the wasteful spending government has incurred. 70M on a payroll system that never was, 8M or there about in CIT, and more to come. At a risk of being seen as using what “aboutism” and being labeled morally bankrupt, I think all the rage about this school is misplaced. If one is so outraged about governance, check out the local government……

Frank Ensence6:12 pm 23 Dec 24

We give the impression that paying board members thousands of dollars in “allowances” and redirecting school fees to pay significant legal fees along with other expenditure is acceptable behaviour. Meanwhile BCC is insolvent.

How much are board members actually paid in allowances? Is paying allowances to board members illegal? It may not look ethical, but may nit be illegal. I don’t know, so any information is appreciated. Who should pay if the entity is sued or taken to a tribunal? Should the entity not be represented for fear of paying from fees?
At the end of the day, even when board members make insane decisions, that end up in court, the entity must be represented appropriately. I don’t see any other way out of it. Happy to be informed if there is a different way.

Daily Digest

Want the best Canberra news delivered daily? Every day we package the most popular Riotact stories and send them straight to your inbox. Sign-up now for trusted local news that will never be behind a paywall.

By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.