Bushfire-hit mirror twins caught in government red tape

Kim Treasure 13 April 2021 24
Peter and David Abel

Mirror twins Peter and David Abel are being denied a Homeowner grant because they are not a couple. Photo: Supplied.

At 68, Mogo mirror twins Peter and David Abel have negotiated all of life’s twists and turns as a united front. Now, the very relationship that has defined them is being used by the Federal Government to deny access to funds to help them rebuild after the Black Summer bushfires.

In what’s been described as a heartless move, the pair who have lived together their whole lives have been denied financial help to rebuild their home because, as brothers, they don’t fit HomeBuilder grant criteria.

“HomeBuilder is only available to an individual or a couple,” David said. “A married couple can get it, defactos can get it, but we can’t because we are brothers.

“And we are not alone. There are others in the area who are brothers, or fathers and sons, and mothers and daughters, who aren’t eligible.

“I was a bit disappointed. I thought they would be more flexible for bushfire victims.”

It’s just one more cruel blow for the twins, who now face a second winter living in a cramped caravan on their Mogo property.

“We’ve had 14 months in a caravan,” David said. “We are either hot or cold, and it’s a small space we are sharing.”

After losing the family home in the Ash Wednesday fires in Victoria, the brothers moved to the South Coast in 1987 and bought their new property in Mogo five years later.


READ ALSO: Demand for mental health support doubles as Rural Fire Service members hit hard by disaster


When the New Year’s Eve fire hit, they stayed to defend their home.

“We had a good fire plan,” David said, “and we thought we had it, then there was a wind change and it came from the south. Sizeable embers got under the pine ceiling and the whole thing burnt down in five minutes.”

Undeterred, the men have gone about rebuilding on their bush block, but the expenses keep mounting. They thought the Federal Government’s HomeBuilder grant would help, but their hopes were crushed by a letter from the office of Housing Minister Michael Sukkar.

“Applicants must be listed on the certificate of title for the property,” it said. “If more than one person is listed on the certificate of title, they must jointly apply for the HomeBuilder grant as a couple. Generally, and as implemented under the Commonwealth’s First Home Loan Deposit Scheme, this would include couples that are legally married, in a registered domestic relationship or those living as a couple on a genuine domestic basis.”

Member for Gilmore Fiona Phillips has gone in to bat for the brothers, and she’s been backed by Opposition Housing spokesperson Jason Clare.

Jason Clare, Peter Abel, David Abel and Fiona Phillips

Opposition Housing spokesperson Jason Clare, with Peter Abel, David Abel and Gilmore MP Fiona Phillips in Mogo. Photo: Supplied.

“We wrote to the [Federal] Government on behalf of Peter and David asking them to have a heart and provide them with the grant,” Ms Phillips said.

“When they applied for a HomeBuilder grant, they were rejected by the Morrison Government because they are not ‘a couple’. And now, to add insult to injury, the government has told them to go and ask a charity for help to rebuild their home.”

Ms Phillips said what was particularly offensive was the direction that “there is a range of other assistance available to people affected by the fires, including grants provided by the Red Cross”.


READ ALSO: Funds to tap into thousands of years of bushfire knowledge


“This is a classic example of a government that just doesn’t get it,” she said. “This isn’t about charity, it’s about fairness.

“If anyone deserves help to rebuild their home it’s brothers like Peter and David who lost their home in the fire and have lived together their whole life.

“Instead of telling Peter and David they should go and see a charity, they should just give them the grant.

“This could be fixed right now with a stroke of a pen. The fact that they won’t shows how heartless they really are.”

Original Article published by Kim Treasure on About Regional.


What's Your Opinion?


Please login to post your comments, or connect with
24 Responses to Bushfire-hit mirror twins caught in government red tape
Asha Kidd Asha Kidd 8:46 pm 18 Apr 21

Is there a go fund me for these guys?

Monica Tiffen Monica Tiffen 9:14 pm 16 Apr 21

Who say's!!! Every day I hear more rubbish! Can't believe we take any notice of such nonesense!!!!

Louise Flood Louise Flood 2:01 pm 16 Apr 21

Others have been denied rural grant help because they could not prove they earned a living off their land in the last two years. But that was because drought made it impossible to make profit. All those LNP promises are worthless and heartless.

Capital Retro Capital Retro 8:10 am 16 Apr 21

Anyone living in or aspiring to live in known bushfire or flood areas should be forced to have property insurance cover as part of their annual expenditure.

This would include most of the existing homes in Canberra, by the way.

Kylie Tinnock Kylie Tinnock 11:27 pm 15 Apr 21

Where’s their insurance company and why isn’t their insurance covering building a new home. The government only has so much money to hand out. Last year was full of disasters. The government can’t give money out to everyone

Pammy Howarth Pammy Howarth 7:26 pm 15 Apr 21

Truly worthy go fund me page I reckon.

Trish Roberts Trish Roberts 5:17 pm 15 Apr 21

This is appalling. They aren’t trying to game the system. They are simply 2 people in a family relationship who need a home. Change the regulations!

David Brown David Brown 5:15 pm 15 Apr 21

I guess they won’t be voting for the government next time around.

    Adam Jovanovic Adam Jovanovic 10:14 pm 17 Apr 21

    You'd be surprised how many people vote for the government that screws them over the most. Mainly.because.of alarmist.and exaggerated issues.which let their.imaginations and fears run wild..

Melissa Henry Melissa Henry 5:14 pm 15 Apr 21

Where is all the money that was raised? I donated and was hoping to see those unable to rebuild make use of the tens of millions of dollars!

    Ian E Wheeler Ian E Wheeler 5:20 pm 15 Apr 21

    Thank you for your donation. It has helped me after I lost everything.

    Amount received *might* have paid for something like the van they're in front of and I fully qualified for help. This was from Red Cross and they have been the most helpful and distributed the great majority of donations.

    Remember the $50+ million given to Celeste Barber had to he given to the RFS.

    Adam Jovanovic Adam Jovanovic 10:12 pm 17 Apr 21

    Lame excuses like money held for the next disaster even though a lot of peoples intention whilst donating at the time was to help the fire victims there and then

    Yet.those charities didn't bother to tell people about that misconception so to me what they basically did was fraud!!

Clive John Trenton Clive John Trenton 4:05 pm 15 Apr 21

On a different note... why did so many have no insurance?

    Cristal Tatterson Cristal Tatterson 11:26 am 17 Apr 21

    Clive John Trenton can't afford it. With the price of living so high who can afford insurance as well? My insurance jumped $50 per month on each car when I moved to a postcode that had been affected by the bushfires. I now can't afford contents insurance.

    Clive John Trenton Clive John Trenton 1:26 pm 17 Apr 21

    Cristal Tatterson that's a risk you take.. why should the government subsidy those without whilst not helping those with?

Karen Groeneveld Karen Groeneveld 3:46 pm 15 Apr 21

Appalling and discriminatory. 😡

Judy Elferkh Judy Elferkh 3:31 pm 15 Apr 21

The government needs to acknowledge that it is almost impossible for most people to live by themselves and must share to cope financially or for health reasons. It makes no sense to discriminate against the two brothers or other people who don't fit the 'couple' description. However those charities saving for future disasters should also be stepping up.

Anne Elizabeth Anne Elizabeth 3:17 pm 15 Apr 21

Outrageous😡

Tricia Lawrence Tricia Lawrence 1:34 pm 15 Apr 21

This is appalling and outrageous. Our politicians and bureaucrats need to look at the needs of those who have suffered so much.

Kat Sychee C Kat Sychee C 1:18 pm 15 Apr 21

I feel for these guys, surely they fit under a domestic arrangement in terms of contributing to the house hold? So...

more serious issues aside, what's the definition of 'mirror' twins? Is that like identical twins but one is left handed and the other right? Twins Research Australia

    Katie Johns Katie Johns 2:58 pm 15 Apr 21

    Kat Sychee C that is correct re mirror twins, plus other reasons

    Sarah Roarty Sarah Roarty 4:41 pm 15 Apr 21

    Kat Sychee C my nieces are mirror twins; it’s where they are a DNA’d mirrored replica of each other, even down to the swirl of hair at the centre of their scalp growing in opposite directions. Instead of looking identical side by side, rather they are identical when they look at each other - it’s like looking in a mirror. There’s probably more to it than that, but that’s my general understanding based on my experience with my nieces.

Mirja Spannari Mirja Spannari 1:00 pm 15 Apr 21

Thats rediculous another example of government stuff ups cut the red tape and do the right human thing.😡

Heather Purvis Heather Purvis 12:46 pm 15 Apr 21

This government has a lot to answer for! 🤨😠😡🤬🤯

CBR Tweets

Sign up to our newsletter

 Top
Region Group Pty Ltd

Search across the site