Democracy and free press must not be casualties of coronavirus war

Ian Bushnell 5 April 2020 17
Prime Minister Scott Morrison

Prime Minister Scott Morrison address the nation on television after a National Cabinet meeting. Photo: File.

It seems we’ve all joined Team Australia in this time of pandemic and economic collapse.

Political opposition parties have been consigned to irrelevance as governments get on with preventing disaster. Federal, state, and territory leaders – Liberal and Labor – sit around the table together, a war cabinet waging a campaign to stave off an invisible enemy and keep the nation afloat.

Mind-boggling, open-ended spending. Freedoms curtailed. New powers legislated. No footy, no festivals, no fun.

And, generally, we have taken it all in our stride as part of what is necessary to avoid both the twin terrors of disease and want.

There have been exhortations to remember our grandparents’ stories of their sacrifices as the nation endured the Great Depression and the war that followed.

Both Prime Minister Scott Morrison and Chief Minister Andrew Barr have been on a unity ticket, urging us to all pull together to get to the other side as soon as we can.

I get that. The stakes are too high for narrow ideological agendas.

But in this kind of atmosphere, criticism can seem bad for morale, hard questions like poor form and doubt an enemy in itself.

Compared with some of the liberties being taken by the world’s strongmen in these times, Australia’s response seems benign but that doesn’t mean we should totally suspend our disbelief along with our parliaments.

The Canberra Liberals, worried about government overreach, last week pushed for more transparency about legislative changes.

The ACT Law Society is concerned about denying the right of a jury trial to accused persons.

There remains issues deserving of our attention that still need to be discussed, debated and resolved.

Playground, Closed Sign

Sign of the times: Playgrounds closed in Canberra. Photo: Region Media.

As journalists feel the pressure to jump on board the team bus for the ride, while facing their own existential threat, they must step back and remember to do their jobs.

They must remember just who they represent, and continue to respectfully talk truth to power and hold our elected leaders to account, even as they see colleagues join the dole queues when media companies lose their advertisers, crunched by the economic shutdown.

If ever there was an essential industry in this fearful public health crisis and time of immense government action it is the media, which can be a source of credible information and a check on the decision-makers.

That includes regional companies such as Region Media, publisher of RiotACT, which in only a few years has become a firm part of the media landscape in the Canberra region, adding to its diversity and providing more choice for its 440,000 residents.

The more credible voices the better, and it is tragic to see regional mastheads having to close – if only temporarily – at a time when they are most needed.

Ironically, the hunger for news and information has never been greater. Newspaper readership is up and website audiences are surging even as revenue pressures grow and hard decisions are contemplated.

If we are all in this together, we cannot afford to let these vital organisations also fall victim to the virus.

For our governments, honesty is still the best policy. Candour and full disclosure should be their side of the bargain in this battle, in which we have conceded them great power, and the authority to spend billions.

For us, we can still be team players and question the skipper. It is OK to demand more information, to query the practicality of a measure, and to advocate for the forgotten or overlooked.

Because when we do get to the other side, we will want our freedoms back.

Come October, we may not have Floriade but we will have, hopefully, our festival of democracy, as Mr Barr calls it.

That will be as good a celebration as any, if by then, the battle is won or at least victory is in sight.


What's Your Opinion?


Please login to post your comments, or connect with
17 Responses to Democracy and free press must not be casualties of coronavirus war
Mark Walton Mark Walton 6:29 pm 07 Apr 20

No problems having free press or the idea that hard questions cannot be asked. But surely the most important question, is who makes the press accountable. Long overdue that the media be made more accountable

Daniel Duncan Daniel Duncan 5:45 pm 07 Apr 20

I will stand up for a free press. Will they stand by us with our free speech... so far nope.

HiddenDragon HiddenDragon 9:08 pm 06 Apr 20

With all the parallels being drawn to war-time, it might be worth remembering that Churchill lost the July 1945 British election in an absolute landslide.

It had, admittedly, been ten years since the previous general election – but that might be a caution to contemporary leaders who are contemplating (where constitutionally possible, of course) “adjusting” electoral cycles.

Acton Acton 2:54 pm 06 Apr 20

The justification given for the removal of our civil liberties and destruction of the economy is that measures are necessary to stop the spread of a virus which will cause deaths among the elderly and those with pre-existing health problems. This then becomes a justification for the permanent removal of civil liberties because certain groups always will be more susceptible to viruses like covid 19. People still don’t understand the difficulty of ever getting back the liberties a government removes.

Capital Retro Capital Retro 1:58 pm 06 Apr 20

How do you exaggerate the worst health crisis in modern history?

The Australian death toll from the current pandemic isn’t yet 50. A few weeks ago some media outlets were screaming it would be thousands.

Compare that with the Spanish Influenza 100 yaers ago when 13,000 Australians died (officially) when the poulation here was barely 5 million people. Which is worst?

Stephen Saunders Stephen Saunders 10:57 am 06 Apr 20

Can’t bear Morrison. But he’s made himself look effective. Leads 53-29. Albanese only got the job because it was “his turn”. Has never shown much interest in presenting as a credible alternative. There’s your democratic problem. It’s not about whether parliament is sitting.

Simon Hiscock Simon Hiscock 10:01 am 06 Apr 20

This is a global pandemic like the world hasn't faced in 100 years. There is almost nothing happening anywhere that isn't related to the crisis as everyone is at home, and the thing is only getting bigger.

As things continue to worsen, so will the news. Once it starts to decline, the news will get better.

Stop blaming the media for the harsh reality we all face.

    Ryan Cantrill Ryan Cantrill 12:06 pm 06 Apr 20

    Simon Hiscock no you’re totally right let’s continue to let overly dramatic/exaggerated, fear inducing, panic stricken covid-19 related media into society into a time of global crisis. I’m sure it will be good for everyone’s mental health.

    Simon Hiscock Simon Hiscock 12:08 pm 06 Apr 20

    How do you exaggerate the worst health crisis in modern history?

    Justin Watson Justin Watson 1:27 pm 06 Apr 20

    Simon Hiscock By sensationlising headlines to sell newspaper. Also the definition of worse is debatable. There are many health crisis all over the world all the time, that kill laarge numbers of poor people. However coronavirus shows no boundaries when it comes to affluency, so the world is doing something about this virus.

Jane Kennedy Jane Kennedy 9:08 am 06 Apr 20

Agree I’m tired of all the negative stories

There must be some positive things happening

    Tod Davis Tod Davis 9:38 am 06 Apr 20

    Jane Kennedy a few weeks ago Donald Trump mentioned in a press conference that there was positive signs in a drug trial. A journalist abused him saying that is was immoral to offer hope

    Charles Black Charles Black 1:08 pm 06 Apr 20

    Tod Davis I think the issue is that medical advice from a person who can barely read is not something that we should entertain.

Ann Chaplin Ann Chaplin 9:01 am 06 Apr 20

YouTube, Netflix and Stan provide much relief from the negativity.

Tod Davis Tod Davis 7:24 am 06 Apr 20

I’ve been extremely frustrated that the media seem to refuse any positive stories. Al the media is telling us is the doom and gloom

    Jacqueline Von Renouard Jacqueline Von Renouard 8:12 am 06 Apr 20

    Tod Davis Not only that but it's constant. Can't turn on free to air TV without being bombarded with Covid19 news. Thank God for paid TV.

    Tod Davis Tod Davis 8:14 am 06 Apr 20

    Jacqueline Von Renouard I’ve developed a phobia of the news

CBR Tweets

Sign up to our newsletter

Top

Search across the site