16 August 2024

Liberals may have shot themselves in the foot with Barr doppleganger bid

| Ian Bushnell
Join the conversation
46
Elizabeth Lee, MLA.

How would Opposition Leader Elizabeth Lee have responded if the boot was on the other foot? Photo: Michelle Kroll.

It’s hard to know what to make of the Canberra Liberals bid for an Andrew Barr lookalike to star in its election campaign ads.

One could say at least they’re not using an AI-generated doppelganger but looking to give a local model/actor a gig.

We don’t know what the ads will look or feel like, whether they will be full-on attack jobs or laced with humour.

Have the Canberra Liberals found in its research, polling or shopping centre chats with punters that the Chief Minister is so on the nose that he may be the government’s weakest link?

Or, to use a cricket analogy, is it the West Indian strategy (when they were at their most fearsome) of targeting the skipper?

Or are they simply copying conservative tactics elsewhere, like in Queensland recently, where the LNP used AI at Premier Stephen Miles’s expense?

READ ALSO The election’s almost here! Can you see the signs?

Labor says it won’t be returning fire in the same way to go after Opposition Leader Elizabeth Lee, who’s keeping quiet and leaving campaign matters to the party machine.

However, one wonders what her response might be if she was given similar treatment and whether she was kept in the loop about the ad strategy.

For Labor, it’s easy meat to counter that the Liberals are simply reverting to stunts instead of talking policy, dismissing them as lacking credibility, but don’t doubt its capacity to go negative as well.

That’s why it is surprising that the Liberals have chosen this path, as well as getting so personal in their attacks on Mr Barr.

The government and Mr Barr have been around for a long time, so there is no shortage of policy attack points, and the Liberals are putting out strategically placed policy positions, hopefully, more frequently, as we edge closer to 19 October.

Ms Lee, despite ongoing internal ructions and tepid support from the old guard, has managed to drag the party towards the centre to give it some chance.

It was important that the party projected competence and vigour to present a menu of solid policies that provided a plausible, positive alternative.

This Barr lookalike attack ad episode seems to have come out of nowhere.

Will undecided voters buy it, or will it just be talking to the rusted-on Libs who already have a certain view of the Chief Minister?

I suspect the latter because this kind of social media-driven negative campaigning does not play that well in an electorate as educated and savvy as the ACT.

Much of the good work that has been done to re-establish the Liberal brand could well be wasted, and surely the party could spend its money elsewhere.

READ ALSO The highs and lows of ACT’s NAPLAN performance

Mr Barr has called it weird and a bit creepy. Unnecessary, undergraduate and juvenile might be other descriptions.

The beneficiaries may be the independents (take your pick), whom disenchanted voters could look to as a safe option.

For some, this episode could be a milestone in the campaign where they mark the Liberals down as improved but still not ready for power.

Join the conversation

46
All Comments
  • All Comments
  • Website Comments
LatestOldest

They probably want someone who looks a bit like Barr to repeat some of the appalling things he’s said about senior citizens and journalists or to repeat some of his many, many, many broken promises to the people of Canberra. Barr has been so arrogant and dismissive towards so many Canberrans that there’s no need for the Libs to put fake words in his mouth – they can just use his own.

Ian Bushnell’s take on it is no surprise however. He consistently cheers for the ACT Labor-Greens government despite their epic failures.

This isn’t in the top 10,000 issues for voters in a couple of months.

HiddenDragon8:40 pm 16 Aug 24

“Mr Barr has called it weird and a bit creepy”

– with that highly original effort as an opening shot in what is shaping up to be yet another dismal campaign, we can probably also look forward to “if you’ve got something to say, say it to my face” and “when we fight, we win”, and maybe even the spectacle of Andy bouncing into staged events to the beat of Beyonce’s ‘Freedom’.

Undergraduate and juvenile best sums up this latest effort from the Canberra Liberals, but what would one expect from this party!
I have noticed Liberal MLA’s and the party’s candidates using A1 manipulated images of the CM and other MLA’s on their Facebook pages over many months now. The party’s leader Elizabeth Lee, a woman of Asian heritage, turns a blind eye but is always quick to react to any perceived racism directed at her. One wonders how she and her party would react if Labor used the same tactics and posted distorted and unflattering images of her or engaged a lookalike for their advertising.
One can only imagine the uproar and indignation coming from Ms Lee and her party should Labor use such tactics.

Oh look out, it’s the female iteration of Jack D. 🤣

I have a bit of an insight into the dysfunction within the Canberra Liberals and the shadow of the party they once were Ken M. Your desperate and sustained attempts at using social media and this site to undermine any criticism reveals you are just a lackey for the party. Unlike Jack D. and his scepticism, I have confidence that the Canberra Liberals will one day break free from their conservative shackles and become the party they were when last elected to government representing the best interests of ACT voters.

Ken M seems deathly afraid of a small L, moderate Liberal party with reasonable views on social issues and climate. The nasty, vitriolic rhetoric only serves to remind everyone of the far-right views that the Canberra Liberals are hiding behind Elizabeth Lee and why they remain unelectable despite the pretence of a moderate “leader”.

Incidental Tourist4:35 pm 16 Aug 24

What’s the problem? I get all sort of brochures in my mailbox. While half of each one is occupied with traditionally smiling photo of candidates yet framed in different colours another half has major talking points. Canberra Liberals have their policies available to everybody on their website and anybody who need details can google “The policies of the next Canberra liberals government”.

In that case, it would appear that the problem is Labor voters can’t read.

Throwing puerile insults at people you need to vote for the Canberra Liberals is an entirely sensible way to win over their support.

It does though highlight the contempt the Liberals and their supporters have for this electorate and why they’re not a reasonable choice as an alternate government.

LOL
Yeah because that’s way different to your BS accusing centrista of being “far right”. 🤣

The lack of self awareness you display is astounding.

Incidental Tourist9:29 pm 16 Aug 24

I was always puzzled why there is no policy contest in this town? Now I seem to understand that labor and green supporters always dismiss as non-existent or offensive anything which does not align to their agenda. It relates not only to Liberals but also to independent candidates like Belco party and even to former ACT Labor leader John Stanhope.

Jeremy Hanson is far right, he’s literally why they’ve tried to hide him behind Lee.

You can continue throwing insults, It doesn’t help the Canberra Libs at all, but it does tell me I’m winning.

Lacks self awareness and is delusional. 🤣

Jeremy Hanson is far right, that’s literally why they moved him out of the deputy leadership. It’s hard to sell the charade that Lee is the leader of a moderate Liberal Party with Hanson literally in leadership. I know dealing with reality is hard.

Ian is spot on in highlighting this stupid stunt by an opposition who should be focused on the real issues.

Now if Ian could also just put a little journalistic effort into reporting on the conga line of failures, stuff ups and empty promises of the current ACT government, he might begin to provide readers with some insight that will help the electorate hold the government to account?

Or option d) Pretend you are going to do something weird and watch everyone’s head explode!

David Watson3:57 pm 16 Aug 24

I suspect the Liberals are finding it difficult to provide any message to “educated and savvy” Canberrans. It must be hard to penetrate the voters of “Cacoon City” where ignorance of the real world and the obvious and unquestioned waste of this government is front and centre of them. The blinkers are really on when they can accept that the CFMEU is any different to other states and accept Mr Barr’s token response to their power in. the ACT. Looks like we are going to sleep through another election.

Agreed David, it is very hard for any conservative voices to gain any traction in this socialist progressive idealistic city. Having a complicit media that is effectively a propaganda machine for Barr & Co, instead of impartial journalists doesn’t help.

But as we all know, being highly educated doesn’t make one smart.

Idiots! If only we had a decent alternative party to Barr’s and Rattenbury’s rip off artists.

Ah, this old chestnut
Literally anybody is a better alternative. Pretending stupid election antics makes a party a poor alternative to literally corrupt Labor who don’t give a rats what the electorate want is absurd.

When will the Liberals learn that ACT voters are smarter than what they give them credit for? We see it at every election, the party relying on silly stunts and slogans because they have no policy substance and nothing else to offer.

The party was rightly punished at the last election for using stunts which were seen to insult the intelligence of ACT voters. Stunts which included meat pies and boxing gloves that were shamelessly lifted from then British conservative leader Boris Johnson’s electoral campaign. It was all very sad really for voters who were looking for maturity and policy substance from our major parties and their leaders. These traits have sadly been lacking from the Liberals over the past two decades and why they will continue to remain in opposition.

If ACT voters keep voting for a party that never delivers on promises and rehashes the same policies they never deliver on each election, and clearly doesn’t care what the electorate want or need, then they are far, far dumber than the Libs are giving them credit for. You’d have to be an utter moron to keep voting Labor.

100%. Alastair Coe’s Debt Freezer (ie an esky with a sticker) managing to make Bojo’s stunt-based politics even lamer was embarrassing at best, and insulting to this electorate at worst.

The Canberra Liberals hiding Jeremy Hanson and the rest of the far right behind Elizabeth Lee is just the latest version of attempting to distract the electorate in an insulting way. Lee won’t stop them from indulging their worst impulses…if they do get in it will be a one-term disaster much like the Campbell Newman government in QLD.

“Anybody not to the left of Marx is far right!”

There’s that deranged Overton window of yours again, Seano. 🤣

The Liberals won’t win with Lee as the leader. Too much of a minnow

“Ms Lee, despite ongoing internal ructions and tepid support from the old guard, has managed to drag the party towards the centre to give it some chance.”

Bwhahahaha….sure….come on, Lee is just a front for the same old far right-wing Liberal Party that Canberrans keep sensibly and resoundingly rejecting.

The Libs are “far right wing”? You’re another one who has shifted their Overton window so far left that anybody a hair to the right of Marx is a Nazi. 🤣

What a ridiculous comment.

You misspelled “accurate”, comrade.

The average Canberra pundit keep voting in the rusted on Labor no matter what. A regular person would find it creepy if someone hired a doppleganger however politically seems to bee fair game. Hanson’s cartoon series is very well put together.

Seems much better than all the promises that Labor are making if they win power at the next election. Why aren’t their policies implemented now?

Check out the one nation ads if you haven’t already. They’re gold

Daily Digest

Want the best Canberra news delivered daily? Every day we package the most popular Riotact stories and send them straight to your inbox. Sign-up now for trusted local news that will never be behind a paywall.

By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.