27 August 2024

Greens pledge to accelerate light rail but Steel says they're dreamin'

| Ian Bushnell
Join the conversation
10
Light rail vehicle parked at Alinga Street station

Getting light rail to Woden is taking too long, say the Greens. Photo: Michelle Kroll.

Canberra’s light rail project is in need of a reboot, say the ACT Greens, who are promising to put the foot down on getting the line to Woden and expanding the network.

The Greens announced their policy at a Public Transport CBR election forum, saying a city-wide network will need a rolling program of planning and construction.

But Transport Minister Chris Steel said the Greens were living in a fantasy and should know better as part of the government.

READ ALSO Barr’s ‘utterly’ failed Tuggeranong: Independents for Canberra candidate takes the long handle to Chief Minister

The Greens have previously criticised the timeline for Stage 2B to Woden, which at present won’t reach the Town Centre until 2033.

They say they will make light rail a government priority with more ambitious deadlines, a bigger project team and the budget funding required to get Stage 2 to Woden moving sooner.

If the project is complex, then they will commit more staff to it, saying the team has been too small with fewer full-time equivalent positions for the first six years of planning than the Stage 1 team had by its second year.

By switching to a rolling program of planning and construction, the project can develop and retain a skilled and stable light rail workforce, the Greens say.

At present, the construction of Stage 2B won’t start at least until 2028, when Stage 2A services to Commonwealth Park are expected to begin.

However, the Greens say that instead of waiting another four years, they will immediately progress with detailed planning and design for Stage 2B so construction can begin while Stage 2A is still being tested and commissioned.

They argue that this will provide better value for money and quicker delivery of future stages.

The Greens will plan for a short extension of Stage 2 to Mawson and begin early planning for future stages of the light rail network to Belconnen, the airport and Tuggeranong.

They will also investigate longer platforms at existing and new stops to accommodate more carriages in anticipation of more passengers using light rail once the line runs all the way from Gungahlin to Woden.

They will also also introduce more frequent light rail services between Gungahlin and the city during the morning and afternoon peaks, on Friday nights and on weekends.

READ ALSO Aviation ombudsman coming to protect passenger rights

Mr Steel said the Greens claims were not grounded in reality.

“They know that we have to move through the Commonwealth approvals processes, which are out of our hands,” he said.

Mr Steel said they hadn’t provided any milestones or a timeline of their own.

He said the idea that the same trades and subcontractors could be kept on throughout different phases of a project and simply rolled on to the next was fanciful.

The government continued to plan for future stages, such as the east-west line from Belconnen to the city and on to the airport, but Labor understood that only one stage could be delivered per decade.

Mr Steel said the government could not afford to run two light rail projects in parallel.

Join the conversation

10
All Comments
  • All Comments
  • Website Comments
LatestOldest
Bennett Bennett7:39 pm 28 Aug 24

Weren’t they the ones that signed us up for the initial leg? Anyway, head over to the Canberra Reddit for an experience in non negotiable gen-z style greens fanaticism. They love unrealistic fantasy land stuff.

The stadium issue emphasises the point that it will be never cheaper than right now. The Greens plan might even save money in the longer term.

This is not remotely correct as delaying capital expenditure where possible is typically the best economic outcome due to inflation. Unless a robust business case can be put together showing that there are clear economic benefits with high cost-benefit ratios, the project shouldn’t go ahead.

Whilst there have been extreme increases in construction costs in recent years post covid, this is not the norm.

And everyone should take the government released stadium costs (and their increases from previous estimates) with a massive grain of salt due to the political message they are trying to push. If you actually believed them, it would further reduce the viability of future stages of light rail which already aren’t justifiable on current figures.

Greens are in denial, they’ve already spent too much money, they’ve racked up so much debt we will soon be taxed $832 million a year just to cover the interest. Wake up Greens, we can’t afford your dreams.

Spending other peoples money is free, in the drug addled fantasy world of the greens.

GrumpyGrandpa1:24 pm 28 Aug 24

With the Greens living in a fantasy, the ALP should cut them loose, save some credibility and be prepared to form a minority government?

By getting into bed with the Greens, the ALP tarnish themselves by the Greens’ ideology.

Margaret Freemantle10:14 pm 28 Aug 24

Agree!! The greens don’t live in the real world…

Daily Digest

Want the best Canberra news delivered daily? Every day we package the most popular Riotact stories and send them straight to your inbox. Sign-up now for trusted local news that will never be behind a paywall.

By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.