16 December 2023

Letter from the Editor: who pays for the sins of the past as small churches are put up for sale?

| Genevieve Jacobs
Join the conversation
22
interior small church

St Brigid’s Quandialla is likely to be sold by the Young parish in the near future. Photo: G Jacobs.

Across rural Australia, small churches are being sold. It’s happening across all denominations: the Anglicans began the process when they sold their rural Tasmanian churches, the diocese of Newcastle followed and now the Catholic Church, in which I was raised.

St Brigid’s Quandialla is a tiny wooden church almost a century old. It sits on land donated by my great uncle Norman, built of timber donated and milled at nearby Bimbi. Every item inside is donated by its people.

On the hot summer mornings of my childhood, the smell of varnish from the slightly sticky pews accompanied Father Cork’s interminable sermons. One day, Stan Nowlan stood up, noting he had several hundred sheep to drench in the yards, so he’d have to leave, thank you, Father.

After Mass, there were cups of tea and kindness and chocolate slice outside the church, produced from picnic baskets and shared beneath the deep shade of white cedar trees planted by my mother and her friends.

I remember us all there – the neighbours and the cousins, Father Brown, who’d been a Rat of Tobruk and smoked too much and drove too fast and tried to teach me how to do the cryptic crossword (unsuccessfully).

READ ALSO Help the RSPCA to help our animals this Christmas – Mr Smiggle needs you!

Now, nearby St Columba’s at Bribbaree will be sold shortly, and locals have been told via the Young Parish newsletter St Brigid’s is next.

Noting a farewell Mass for Bribbaree, the newsletter says “There will be a similar gathering at a later date, when arrangements are made for the sale of the Quandialla Church”. This was news to Quandialla locals.

Declining rural populations and the shortage of priests will be mentioned, but these are not the only reasons.

For years, communities like ours held their own services with or without a priest. And the church is still very much wanted for events like my Aunty Barbara’s funeral this year where the doors were opened wide for an overflowing congregation.

There’s something more unfair, more prosaic and bitter at the root of all this – the collapse of the Catholic Church’s insurance agency on the back of multiple, wide-ranging claims of sexual abuse by clergy and in church-run institutions.

Catholic Church Insurance is facing likely irresolvable financial turmoil due to abuse claims – an estimated $381 million in liabilities relating to professional standards payouts to various church entities, including dioceses and charities.

A rescue effort is underway and may or may not succeed. But in the meantime, centralised parishes are cutting costs wherever possible.

READ ALSO ‘Please don’t pat the dog’: Amanda says many still don’t know the rules around guide dogs

Small rural communities who built, ran and entirely sustained their churches, fundraised for them continuously, donated their time and money and their faith are bearing the consequences of heinous crimes and mismanagement perpetrated by the clergy and church hierarchy.

The payments are necessary, just and fundamentally important compensation. But in an organisation with such diverse assets, there must be other solutions than a unilateral decision to sell the real estate.

How much money can there be in tiny rural churches in small remote communities compared to the pain caused by their sale? Why not allow parishioners to either buy back the church or pay the insurance?

Quandialla is a tiny place, 150 people at best. It’s smaller than it used to be, but the community is still strong, like many other small places around regional Australia.

Everything I’ve ever done to serve the community comes from growing up in that small world bounded by Bland Creek and Grenfell Rd.

In Quandialla, we won’t give up without a fight. It’s what we’ve always done: work together, depend on our own resources and find our own solutions. If only the Catholic Church will meet us halfway.

Join the conversation

22
All Comments
  • All Comments
  • Website Comments
LatestOldest

Quite so Capital Retro – plenty of critics (with both valid and dumb criticisms)but when the rubber hits the road – missing in action!

GrumpyGrandpa7:53 pm 16 Dec 23

It is a peculiar arrangement where Offerings made by the Congregation (from their after-tax income) is used to buy, pay loan repayments and meet other property costs, yet the title always stand in the name of a property trust, owned by a church corporate entity.

There are reasons for this. In whose name would the title otherwise stand? A Church Congregation is a group of people who are changing, arriving, leaving, passing away etc; the individuals aren’t permanent and their financial and non-financial contributions vary.

I have empathy for those who now find that their local Congregation is no longer financially viable, as to employ a Minister.

My mother’s Church shared a Minister with a number of other small towns. Church Services were in a different town each week.

Particularly in small country towns, “Church” can be something that brings people together and when decisions by their corporate overlords are made to sell off the assets paid for by the community, it is a sad day.

Sure, without a permanent Minister, Lay folk can run Services and cover their costs, but they are just marking time. In mother’s case, while they finding a Minister to conduct her funeral, was difficult.

In the comments, there was a suggestion that the Church members buy back the premises. I’d say that by the time that a Church closes, there’s only a few people left and there’s just no money.

Sad as it is, it’s utimately, better that properties are sold, rather than left to deteriorate and run into disrepair.

Amanda Kiley1:45 pm 16 Dec 23

It is hard to swallow when you see the wealth held in the Vatican and the large jewells on the fingers of the Pope and Archbishops. The communities who put. their heart and hard earned cash towards churches are the ones who suffer, and those who kept child abuse a secret live in comfort. It’s actually disgusting.

Capital Retro8:14 am 17 Dec 23

Can you please provide some evidence of your claims, Amanda?

@Capital Retro
Are you suggesting that there was no cover up, by certain members of the Catholic hierarchy, of child sexual abuse, CR?

Brendan Vernon12:47 pm 16 Dec 23

Is there not a community hall?

Capital Retro11:59 am 16 Dec 23

I think some of you are making an adverse judgment about a local matter rather than looking at the bigger picture.

Most religions exist to assist those in need in our global communities and that’s where the proceeds of this sale will go.

I have close friends in the Catholic, Jewish and Salvation Army organizations who voluntarily give lots of their time and resources in helping the disadvantaged within our Canberra community especially at this time of the year.

How many of you critics out there are cooking for the homeless on Christmas Day?

Religion isn’t just about “bible bashing” you know.

Malcolm Roxburgh10:49 am 16 Dec 23

Just one of the many problems, with today’s religion.

The way you put it, GJ, it does seem pretty unfair. The community provided everything (land, building, ongoing expenses), everything except the syndicated denominational Sunday-service rites. And now the parish claims it’s all theirs to flog off.

I suppose the parish’s point is that the title deed is in the Church’s name, secured back in a time nobody imagined the community’s hard work being seized by a faraway clerical bureaucracy to pay off somebody else’s misdeeds. It may belong to the corporate church in a decontextualised legal sense, but is a betrayal of the congregation and the community. It exposes the contradiction of a church as a top-down clerical corporation versus church as a grassroots religious community, and above all is deeply unethical.

Daily Digest

Want the best Canberra news delivered daily? Every day we package the most popular Riotact stories and send them straight to your inbox. Sign-up now for trusted local news that will never be behind a paywall.

By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.