The Preacher only guilty of inflicting grievous bodily harm

johnboy 2 March 2011 16

the preacher at Ainslie shops

The Canberra Times informs us that acting Justice Jane Mathews has bought the “not trying to kill when stabbing in the head” defence of Isa Islam:

A street preacher who stabbed his former neighbour at an inner-north takeaway shop has been found not guilty of attempted murder.

But acting Justice Jane Mathews has found Isa Islam guilty of intentionally inflicting grievous bodily harm on short-order cook Andrew Dyer in July 2009.

Previous reporting is available here.


What's Your Opinion?


Please login to post your comments, or connect with
16 Responses to The Preacher only guilty of inflicting grievous bodily harm
Filter
Order
Chop71 Chop71 11:51 am 02 Mar 11

Of course he is Not Guilty as it happened in the ACT

Chop71 Chop71 11:52 am 02 Mar 11

…the only guilty people here are the people who get caught by speed cameras and DUIs

Davo111 Davo111 1:20 pm 02 Mar 11

Canberra, the place to murder people and get away with it.

TVStar TVStar 1:30 pm 02 Mar 11

Now that must have been one bad $10 lunch.

colourful sydney racing identity colourful sydney racing identity 1:35 pm 02 Mar 11

Of course you were all in court and heard all the evidence right? Right?

johnboy johnboy 1:38 pm 02 Mar 11

Ever stab someone in the head and leave them a tetraplegic for fun CSRI?

colourful sydney racing identity colourful sydney racing identity 1:45 pm 02 Mar 11

johnboy said :

Ever stab someone in the head and leave them a tetraplegic for fun CSRI?

That is for the courts to decide.

PBO PBO 1:50 pm 02 Mar 11

Justice Jane Mathews – Give yourself an uppercut and go back to school. Why are they trying so hard not to have any murder or attempted murder charges in the ACT?

Heavs Heavs 3:07 pm 02 Mar 11

DPP fail again. On fire this week.

Pommy bastard Pommy bastard 4:04 pm 02 Mar 11

I draw the honourable members attention to the reply I gave earlier.

Pommy bastard said :

Admitting to stabbing someone? Gotta be worth a few weekends home detention in the ACT.

But if he’s homeless? Just let him go then.

Tooks Tooks 4:37 pm 02 Mar 11

Chop71 said :

…the only guilty people here are the people who get caught by speed cameras and DUIs

Yes, the nearly full AMC is filled with drink drivers and speeders. Do me a favour and slap yourself in the face.

Stevian Stevian 6:19 pm 02 Mar 11

johnboy said :

Ever stab someone in the head and leave them a tetraplegic for fun CSRI?

That’s the only reason I do it. If he dies a a result, that’s gravy.

bleebleeblee bleebleeblee 12:25 pm 03 Mar 11

@ #6, I don’t think Isa does much for ‘fun’. He’s deluded and unstable.

If we had a mental health system that came close to working in the ACT he might, just maybe, have got the attention he needed before he caused so much grief and harm to other people.

cleo cleo 11:09 pm 25 May 11

That’s one lenient sentence, the victim has to live with what this LOST god follower did to him.
Yes we do need a mental health asylum, isn’t one supposed being built in Canberra, the sooner the better.

Lookout Smithers Lookout Smithers 12:20 am 26 May 11

I am grateful the courts were able to deliver this justice. Still some out there who have not had a day in court and probably wont ever. Getting nothing is the ultimate injustice. Lets give thanks here.

minniemay minniemay 1:10 am 26 May 11

So I guess this should be a getting stabby in Ainslie reminder?

CBR Tweets

Sign up to our newsletter

Top

Search across the site