9 December 2024

Antisemitism fast becoming an Australian election issue

| Chris Johnson
Join the conversation
72
ACT Jewish Centre

Antisemitism is sharply on the rise in Australia and Peter Dutton is making sure it’s part of election rhetoric. Photo: ACT Jewish Centre.

Antisemitism isn’t usually an Australian election issue, but it is shaping up to be firmly in people’s minds when they head to the polls next year.

Peter Dutton is blaming Anthony Albanese for making Australia less safe since the October 7 Hamas attacks in Israel last year, saying he has “sold out” the Australian Jewish community.

The Opposition Leader has used his strongest language yet to condemn the Prime Minister for not calling out last week’s attack on a Melbourne synagogue as an act of terror.

“If people are attacking a place of worship, a religious gathering point, then we know that that is a terrorist attack,” Mr Dutton said on Sunday (8 December).

“And the Prime Minister hasn’t had the guts to come out and say that, but every Australian knows that’s exactly what’s happened.

“And I want to make sure that the Jewish community here in Australia hears a very clear message from the Coalition that we will always support them.”

But shortly after Mr Dutton’s statement, the Prime Minister did indeed label the arson attack on Melbourne’s Adass Israel Synagogue an act of terrorism.

While an official declaration of terrorism is for state authorities to determine, Mr Albanese said his personal view was that it was an obvious terrorist attack.

“Quite clearly, terrorism is something that is aimed at creating fear in the community, and the attacks on the synagogue in Melbourne clearly were,” he said on Sunday.

“And therefore, from my personal perspective, it certainly fulfils that definition of terrorism.”

The PM had already described the attack as an “atrocious act” and committed $32.5 million to the Executive Council of Australian Jewry to further enhance security at Jewish community sites, including synagogues and schools.

He said antisemitism has no place in Australia and the Federal Government unequivocally condemns it.

READ ALSO Worrying signs for Labor with an election looming

“The Jewish community has made an extraordinary contribution to the strength and success of our nation over generations,” Mr Albanese said.

“This grant of $32.5 million will enable the community to provide support and security on the basis of priorities established by the community themselves.

“Antisemitism is disgraceful, and I unequivocally condemn it in all its forms.

“Every Australian has the right to be proud of who they are and to feel welcome, safe and supported in Australia.”

Attorney-General Mark Dreyfus said there was no higher priority than community safety for the Federal Government.

“Antisemitism has no place in Australia. We all have a responsibility to fight against it,” he said.

“This announcement builds on previous support for the Jewish community, including funding for increased security, criminalising doxxing and banning the Nazi salute and hate symbols.”

The new funding will enhance security resources for Jewish schools, pre-schools and other communal facilities used by the Jewish community through risk and threat assessments; critical incident planning; upgrades of security camera systems, monitoring and training; crisis management support; and security guard services.

But it’s not enough for Peter Dutton, who says the Prime Minister has not done enough to help keep Jewish people in Australia safe.

“I think it’s clear to every Australian that the level of antisemitism and hatred that we’re seeing in our community is absolutely unacceptable,” the Opposition Leader said.

“A place of worship is sacrosanct and people should go to a church, or go to a synagogue, or a mosque, or a temple – wherever it might be — and they should be able to practice their religious beliefs freely.

“We’ve now got armed guards at Jewish schools, places of gathering, etc. There’s a security presence there, and that just doesn’t have any place in our society.

“I think what the Prime Minister did after the October 7 attacks in Israel was to completely abrogate his moral responsibility.

“He didn’t condemn strongly enough the actions that we saw on the steps of the Opera House on October 9, and the months and months of protest and hatred and vitriol that was expressed on our university campuses, again, gave rise to ugly incidents.

“And, of course, now it’s escalated to a point where we’ve seen this firebombing, which very clearly is a terrorist attack.”

READ ALSO Will Canberra bashing work for Dutton where it didn’t for Morrison?

Mr Dutton’s language over the issue has intensified since Australia, along with 157 other countries – including major allies except for the United States – supported a United Nations resolution last week to demand an end of Israel’s “unlawful presence in the Occupied Palestinian Territory as rapidly as possible” and build momentum towards a two-state solution.

The Opposition Leader said the move means Labor has sold out Australia’s Jewish community.

Israel’s Ambassador to Australia, Amir Maimon, during a media interview, expressed his disappointment with the vote but did not blame the government for the rise in antisemitism in Australia.

“I don’t hold the government, the Albanese government, responsible for the rise,” he said.

“But I do urge the Albanese government to take all necessary actions and steps in order to uproot this ugly phenomena and to make sure that Jewish people, whether they live in Canberra or in Melbourne and Sydney or elsewhere, will feel safe and secure.”

Join the conversation

72
All Comments
  • All Comments
  • Website Comments
LatestOldest

“Peter Dutton is blaming Anthony Albanese for making Australia less safe since the October 7 Hamas attacks in Israel last year, saying he has “sold out” the Australian Jewish community.”

I may be wrong but the only one who seems to be inciting any antagonism is Dutton – in his attempts to gain political mileage out of a sad situation. I haven’t heard one word from Albanese suggesting that any member of the Australian Jewish community is complicit in what is happening in Gaza.

What Dutton seems to forget is that Australia has favoured a two-state solution to resolve the conflict in the Middle East for several decades. There has been an Australian Representative Office in the West Bank city of Ramallah since 2000. Is it Dutton’s policy to support Israel’s destruction of Palestine?

Decrying the slaughter of innocent non-combatant Palestinian men, women and children is not a show of support for Hamas – they are deservedly listed as a terrorist organisation by the Aust govt, nor is it antisemitic. Similarly, it is not Islamophobic to denounce the actions of Hamas in October last year. Both parties (Hamas and IDF), with their indiscriminate attacks against innocent civilians, are demonstrating the antithesis of the tenets of their respective faiths.

Stronger action is needed to stop these types of arson attacks on cars, buildings and places of worship. A weak finger wagging, tut-tutting insipid, if not begrudged reaction will not discourage, but only prompt escalating attacks. If more visible and determined action is not taken, next may come random attacks on people in the streets, shopping centres and schools, followed by revenge attacks as community harmony disintegrates. Yes, a worse case scenario but Australia works as a multicultural country because we do not tolerate intolerance and we insist all migrants leave behind their ancient feuds and animosities to live together peacefully in their new chosen homeland.
What should be happening now is a show of inter-faith solidarity – a joint and very public meeting and statement from religious leaders – Jewish, Christian, Islamic, even Buddhist condeming these attacks. Community leaders from both sides also need to be seen standing together. What’s been happening in Israel is horrible for all concerned but is not an excuse for turning on fellow Australians.

@Acton
Absolutely agree … and it certainly doesn’t help with morons like Liberal Senator Jane Hume suggesting the attackers were “emboldened, if not enabled” by the government. Trying to get political mileage out of these horrid actions against innocent people is about as low as it gets.

Logicalusername7:56 pm 10 Dec 24

Earlier this year I had to go overseas for business. At the check-in counter SydInt airport I asked the polite gentleman on where his accent was from, he replied “Israel, please do not tell anyone”. He was visibly shaken with a worried look on his face, I assured him, his secret would be safe.

John Pedestrian9:28 am 10 Dec 24

Firebombing a synagogue or a church temple or mosque is a very serious, very real attack . As are the countless other cases of vandalism and personal attacks on Jewish Australians. The response of our authorities to these things to date has been piss weak

Capital Retro9:25 am 10 Dec 24

Australia’s natural deaths in 2023 was 7,040 people per million.
There are about 2 million people in Gaza so using the same natural mortality rate as Australia (although it is probably higher in Gaza) about 14,000 people died in Gaza last year without deaths from the war which the Palestinian elected Hamas terrorists started anyway.
No evidence of genocide there at all.

So the extra 30,000 people just don’t count then? Sounds like your usual ‘take’ on things…

Capital Retro10:12 am 10 Dec 24

JS9, perhaps you can supply proof and dates of that?

@Capital Retro
Would the names of the 34,344 Palestinians, killed by Israeli attacks in the war, as at Oct 2024, suffice, CR?
https://www.aljazeera.com/program/newsfeed/2024/10/7/the-names-of-those-killed-in-israels-genocide-in-gaza

Oh, and before you dismiss the figures, because the link is to Al Jazeera media, this article from Le Monde gives a good account of why the figures are accepted by most international media:
https://www.lemonde.fr/en/les-decodeurs/article/2024/10/13/why-the-gaza-health-ministry-s-death-count-is-considered-reliable_6729264_8.html

I know your allergic to using Google CR, you’ve probably got some conspiracy theory about search engines too.

There is plenty of research out there, as JS has shown below.

Capital Retro8:38 am 11 Dec 24

Plenty of research reveals the HAMAS controlled statistics can’t be verified by an independent source too.
While you’re at it, tell me how many of these claimed innocents killed were active HAMAS terrorists given that 80% of Palestinians support HAMAS.

Mass immigration that both parties support (despite public opposition) is the underlying problem. If you import the world you are going to see all the world’s ethnic conflicts also imported, especially if there is no effort made for assimilation, and further if the rate is too high for that to even be possible.

What a load of garbage.

Australia is a largely peaceful nation that was built by immigrants, particularly post-war. The nation may be becoming increasingly split on the issue but we’re still seen as a country that welcomes migrants and most migrants who settle here feel accepted.

This tired anti-immigrant rhetoric doesn’t stand up in the face of the reality of modern Australia.

Who said anti-immigrant? Immigration rates prior to 1996 were sustainable. Half a million a year and growing is absolutely not. Also, we used to spend money on assimilation programs. We don’t anymore. We now effectively have colonies of unassimilated groups in Sydney and Melbourne. That’s just setting up problems for the future, not an anti-immigrant sentiment. I myself am second generation – neither of my parents were born Australian. Except for me, all of my immediate family were at one time working for the Department of Immigration.

“Who said anti-immigrant?”…proceeds to post an anti-immigrant screed.

“Immigration rates prior to 1996 were sustainable. Half a million a year and growing is absolutely not.” based on what? Feels?

Assimilation happens over time, it always has.

Do you think there is some sort of magic dirt here that magically transforms people into Australians? Far be it from me to praise a government program, but we actually did used to have good assimilation programs that worked hard to insure that assimilation happened. We don’t do that any more, partly because of the absolute scale (10-14 times higher rate than we had in the 90s due to a deliberate decision by the Keating government and maintained since). We also can and have predict problems fairly easily. The Cronulla riots were predicted at the time the third wave from the Lebanese civil war were brought across 15 years earlier. We knew the people we were bringing would have difficult assimilating and that we weren’t prepared to put the resources into ensuring it was done. These problems always have very length lead times. It’s much worse now that the Department of Immigration has been purged of anyone with corporate knowledge about why things were done the way they were.

I didn’t go to assimilation class. Now I say gday how yer going mate to everyone, I love Vegemite & snags on the bbq, Aussie rules best game in the world. Is that assimilation??? Face it mate Australia is multicultural country, like it or not!!!

“Do you think there is some sort of magic dirt here that magically transforms people into Australians?”

Yes, champion I do. Australia is a multicultural country. You only have to look at our sporting teams to see how many different cultures are represented but all Australians.

“The Cronulla riots were predicted at the time the third wave from the Lebanese civil war were brought across 15 years earlier.”

By who? And that’s the best you’ve got? Nearly two decades ago (and largely egged on by right-wing shock jocks)? How many riots since? Or before?

Yes, incidents happen but the fact that they happen rarely proves that Australia is a peaceful country where immigrants are welcomed and assimilate well. The claims otherwise are a complete beat-up usually promoted by racists, not by any real assessment of Australia or our genuine embrace of immigrants and the need for them in the future.

Capital Retro9:05 am 11 Dec 24

You are 100% correct, The Silver.
If anyone wants proof that “assimilation” has failed, take a trip to Lakemba and count the number of satellite dishes all receiving over 50 free channels of stuff from the countries they came from.

What are you on about?

Firstly how is that proof of anything? Secondly, satellite dishes? What decade are you living in champ? Thirdly, what business is it of yours what information and entertainment people consume in their own homes? Fourthly, have you been to Lakemba? I have, seems pretty integrated to me. Integrated doesn’t mean we all have to be one homogenous group even though some sad pathetic people seem to think that everyone different to them is somehow wrong.

PS. You know what’s UnAustralian? Sticking your big beak in other people’s business.

Capital Retro6:06 pm 11 Dec 24

You are skewing the debate, as usual.
Integration involves contact and identification with both cultures.
Assimilation involves identification with the host country’s culture and non-acceptance of one’s heritage culture.
Both have failed with certain people who have migrated to Australia.
Free satellite services here: https://www.satellitetoday.com/connectivity/2013/11/18/free-to-air-satellite-tv-channels-in-the-arab-world-the-growth-in-supply-continues/
And for younger people over 700 Arabic channels can be streamed (whatever that means) for free.
Yes, I have been to Lakemba, my wife used to live there.
You must of missed the civil celebrations in Lakemba that were on TV the night of the HAMAS massacre in Israel last year. The rest of Australia wasn’t celebrating though.
It’s nothing to do with other people’s business coming from you is meaningless.

I’m not skewing the debate because your points are dumb and don’t stand up.

“Assimilation involves identification with the host country’s culture and non-acceptance of one’s heritage culture.
Both have failed with certain people who have migrated to Australia.”

Who says and based on what? Other than racism of course.

What do satellites prove? Seriously?

“And for younger people over 700 Arabic channels can be streamed (whatever that means) for free.”

The fact that people in Lakemba can stream these channels kinda defeats this dumb point anyway…not that not knowing what streaming is stops you from coming to these ridiculous conclusions.

“You must of missed the civil celebrations in Lakemba that were on TV the night of the HAMAS massacre in Israel last year.”

Peaceful protest in support of Palestine is not a celebration of a massacre. You talk about skewing the debate this is just racist spin.

“It’s nothing to do with other people’s business coming from you is meaningless.”

This comment is meaningless. Making judgements based on what you assume people are watching in the privacy of their own homes says a lot about you and your views. This stickybeak, busybody stuff is more un-Australian than having a satellite dish.

HiddenDragon8:58 pm 09 Dec 24

Issues relating to Israel/Palestine/Gaza will certainly be hot topics in some electorates, but still a relatively small number – for all the rest, the issue will be broader and will be along the lines of how our political leaders deal with imported strife of all sorts in a liberal democracy .

Thus far, we’ve had Albanese going through the motions of saying at least some of the things you would expect to hear from a PM, and similarly Dutton, but both look like they have chosen a side and are wrapping their partisan choices in a fairly thin veneer of Australian values when most voters would probably prefer to have an unequivocal articulation of Australian values front and centre.

Liberals are clearly anti Arab. Anti Ukraine and anti Taiwanese too???

Marise thoughtlessly over-generalises. And misdirects her pieties too?

What has happened in Melbourne is inexcusable, but its about time Israel has a bit of a think about what it might be doing to contribute to the rise of such behaviour.

Effectively they’ve come full circle and are doing in Gaza what was done to their people in the 1940s….. and they wonder why some aren’t looking on it so favourably.

“What has happened in Melbourne is inexcusable, but it’s about time Israel has a bit of a think about what it might be doing to contribute to the rise of such behaviour.”

What, by defending itself after 1200 men, women and children were slaughtered by Hamas and two hundred were taken hostage?

I must have missed the bit where the Jews proclaimed Germany shouldn’t exist and vowed to destroy it, or when Jewish terrorists murdered hundreds of Germans at a music festival back in 1939. I’ll gather you’ll be updating the appropriate wiki entries to cover this part of German/NAZI history?

Glad to see some on here are drinking the kool aid as well. There is zero excuses for what triggered this whole incident. But likewise, their is zero excuses for a campaign that effectively has an aim of wiping an entire ‘state’ (Lets not get into that argument) from the map – men, women and children included. The response of Israel is every bit as evil as what started it – and they have effectively come full circle.

Palestine and heir mates would have wiped out Israel if they had a half decent army and Israel didn’t have such good defences. I must have missed the bit were Palestine terrorists murdered Israelis at the ’72 Munich Olympics or the spate of hijacks and plane bombings by the same murderous group in the 70s. The issue here and the original article is what is happening in Australia and all we see is hate and vile directed at the Jews in the form of violence and now firebombing. There has been virtually no retaliation from the Jews, it has all been one way abuse from the Arabs and their mates. Our left wing government has been utterly useless in protecting the rights of Jewish Australians.

Sound like you’re the one who needs to have a bit of a think, JS9, and cough up all the Hamas Koolaid you’ve been drinking. Once again progressive ideology comes up short. Don’t make excuses for Jew hatred, and educate yourself as to who Hamas are and what they state their aims are. But hey, you won’t.

Shameful that the slaughter of thousands of women and children by the IDF is not an election issue. Targeting people of the Jewish faith just because of their faith is wrong. Criticising genocide is not.

So how about the 1200 Issalise that were slaughtered by Hamas? And the chant ‘from the river to the sea’ is calling for the genocide of Israel.

Capital Retro11:24 am 10 Dec 24

And the hostages who are never mentioned sympathetically by the UN. Imagine the hell they are going through.

No one is denying the hell they are going through. But you are also actively denying the hell the people of Gaza are going through as well – I’m not talking about the scum of hamas, but the innocent men, women and children caught in the middle. That vastly outnumber the 1200 you care so desperately about.

Your trying to claim in other comments there haven’t been any deaths above ‘natural rates’….. so obviously only some people matter in your mind.

Absurd to claim that calling out Israel for bloody terrorism is antisemitism. Deliberate confusion to hide Israel’s crimes

It seems that individuals HAVE to call Israel out for its genocide because our Parliament will not. Anti Israeli is NOT anti semitism.

Israel’s crimes?? Unbelievable! There was peace in the Middle East until Hamas and several other Palestinian militant groups launched a coordinated attack on Israel from the Gaza Strip. This marked the beginning of the ongoing Israel-Hamas war. Over 1200 Islael’s slaughtered (men, women and children), women were raped, people tortured, and hostages were taken. They still have the hostages, the ones that are still alive that is. Yet you don’t mention any of that in your antisemitic rant. What would you expect Australia to do if the same thing happened to us? Would you call us terrorists if we attacked the terrorists?

Come on dazzer, did you take that from the Israeli talking points.

Are you really comfortable the response from Israel has in any shape or form been proportionate? What is it now – an estimated 45,000 Palestinians killed? More than half of homes in Gaza destroyed or seriously damaged, most commercial facilities damaged.

Wiping a state from the earth, as they are effectively doing, is hardly peace loving, and Israel has a long and chequered history of not contributing much to peace in the region.

It is not anti-semitic to call out the fact that Israel has committed clear crimes in their response to those terrible actions.

Just like murdoch’s mouthpiece (aka dutton) starting a non issue and overacting like he’s the moral police…… thank God (or whatever higher being) there is other reliable real NEWs outlets that provide a balanced insight instead of the trash from murdoch’s rags…

Of course, the typical leftie reaction is ‘it’s Murdoch’s media fault’. Overreaction? A place of worship being firebombed with people inside, people could have been killed. Plus, all the other attacks on Jews and threatening behaviour against them. It’s the Murdoch media who provide the balance not like the Labor/Greens propaganda arm the ABC and the rest of the left-wing media.

dazzer, what’s your take on the Leader of the Opposition refusing to let one of his team, James Paterson, read out a statement from Josh Burns, a Jewish MP (who couldn’t attend the event due to illness) after the attack on the synagogue. sounds like anti-semitism to most of us. And, yeah, a low act from a low individual.

How many people have Israel killed in Gaza in response Dazzler?

And pretending the Murdoch Media provide ‘balance’ says it all really about your views, which have about as much balance as Scomo after a trip to Engadine Maccas.

What do you expect when Hamas deliberately hide amongst the civilian population, like in hospitals, etc., And who is reporting the casualties in Gaza…the Palestinian Health Authority, which is Hamas. If you believe their casualty figures, you must believe in Santa Claus. And you think the ABC provides balance…. It shows what an extreme lefty you are.

@dazzer
OK, since you are a paragon of political objectivity and are fully informed – what are the real figures of Palestinian civilian deaths in the Gaza conflict, and obviously you can cite the source?

Julie Lindner1:17 pm 09 Dec 24

Talk about making a mountain out of a mole hill. Hopefully, both major parties lose control of both houses of parliament and more intelligent independents start running Australia.

One can only hope. And although I would like to stress that I am most definitely not anti-semitic in the sesne that I have no opinion one way or the other about the Jewish religion-If the government of a country continues to commit atrocities and genocide against a people then international reaction, both rational and irrational, is bound to occur. It is up to the people of Isreal to put a stop to their murderous government policies and not foreign governments responsibility to support them with ensuing criminal and viloent results.

Daily Digest

Want the best Canberra news delivered daily? Every day we package the most popular Riotact stories and send them straight to your inbox. Sign-up now for trusted local news that will never be behind a paywall.

By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.