Education Directorate defends asbestos handling in schools after spate of incidents

Dominic Giannini 19 March 2021 12
Yvette Berry

Education Minister Yvette Berry. Photo: Michelle Kroll.

The Education Directorate has defended its procedures and practices after a series of incidents exposed asbestos sheeting fragments and disturbed lead paint in ACT schools.

According to documents obtained by Region Media under Freedom of Information, it has been revealed that a staff member – because of “human error” – accidentally disturbed asbestos-containing material at Melba Copland Secondary School. All staff subsequently had to undergo refresher training in the aftermath of the incident.

A Ministerial Brief to Education Minister Yvette Berry dated 12 February 2020 identified a “management breakdown” in procedures at the school, and the prevalence of asbestos-awareness training and induction processes on-site were reviewed.

An Education Directorate spokesperson did not directly answer questions about whether training processes were insufficient at the time.


READ MORE: Government releases list of 76 public schools with hazardous materials


Less than six months later, on 30 June, a fragment of bonded asbestos sheeting was found in the soil of a restricted access area of Melba Copland Secondary School.

The area was tested and 5 cm of topsoil was removed from a two-metre radius by 5 July. A clearance certificate was issued the next day; however, a notice to the school community was still being prepared two weeks after the asbestos sheeting fragment was originally found, the briefing revealed.

On 2 July 2020 at Forrest Primary School, children were digging holes up to 30 cm deep in the playground when they discovered building debris, including a 10 cm fragment of bonded asbestos sheeting.

One child was reported to have been hitting the fragments with a shovel.

An exclusion zone was created and testing of the material was carried out four days later. Remediation works by licensed removalists were undertaken 10 days later. A subsequent scan of the grounds found no more surface debris.

These incidents occurred less than two years after the final report of an audit into asbestos management in ACT public schools was distributed.


READ ALSO: Power problems short circuit plan for Lawson Two development


“Forrest Primary School was built in the 1950s when asbestos was a commonly used building product,” an Education Directorate spokesperson said.

“The fragment of bonded asbestos was most likely buried underground as part of building debris when the school was constructed [which] was a relatively common building practice at the time.

“The licenced asbestos assessor advised that there was negligible risk of exposure from this find.”

Regarding Melba, the spokesperson said, “the source of that asbestos is historic, and cannot be tied to any recent activity”.

Further briefs provided to Ms Berry also included advice from Robson Environmental that a contractor hired by the school in the Gambarri Centre contributed to the elevated levels of lead dust found at the Yarralumla Primary School in July last year.

Lead-containing dust found at Yarralumla Primary School resulted from the removal of the windows, changes to the airflow due to the removal of the windows and painting work being done by another contractor at the same time, the spokesperson said.

When asked if the ACT Government has delegated the responsibility to manage hazardous materials in schools, the spokesperson said that schools have a maintenance budget and that contractors must check hazardous material plans before undertaking work in schools.

New processes were then flagged to ensure that future works, including painting, scheduled to be carried out in Education Directorate buildings that contain hazardous materials, would be solely managed by Infrastructure and Capital Works rather than the schools themselves.


READ ALSO: When is gentrifying your Canberra neighbourhood a good idea?


The additional processes enacted the following month were to ensure that schools with hazardous materials must check with the directorate’s infrastructure team to make sure works are conducted in accordance with hazardous materials protocols.

Following media coverage of lead dust being found at Yarralumla Primary School in July last year, a concerned parent wrote to the Minister in early August requesting information on lead levels at the Curtin Primary School.

Six areas that needed remediation were subsequently found a month later when an assessment was carried out.

The directorate said work was already scheduled for Curtin Primary School and that the parent’s concerns expedited the process.

“Feedback from school communities on the condition of our schools is valuable and does assist us in prioritising our maintenance inspections,” the spokesperson said.

“In this case, feedback from the school community led to fast-tracking the already planned work.”


What's Your Opinion?


Please login to post your comments, or connect with
12 Responses to Education Directorate defends asbestos handling in schools after spate of incidents
Anthony Briscoe Anthony Briscoe 6:29 pm 21 Mar 21

If Yvette Berry has anything to do with it you can expect another stuff up

Alison Jones Alison Jones 3:05 pm 21 Mar 21

The school our children went to (in one case still attends) was among those with issues with lead. School kept us as parents clearly informed and there was no risk to the students. I thought the school did all that could be expected on this issue. I am sorry if other parents elsewhere did not feel as well informed but after our excellent experience, I'm quite happy with how the government had handled this issue.

Linda Stapleton Linda Stapleton 6:30 pm 20 Mar 21

We use to live across from the Harrison school when they were removing the asbestos... it was always so much fun having the stuff blowing around the neighbourhood and onto our balcony while it was meant to be being removed, oh so safely... wondering how many years before those living in the area start to show up at their local Drs with medical conditions caused from the stuff....

bj_ACT bj_ACT 3:40 pm 20 Mar 21

As a few of us raised the other week, how can the Namadgi Superschool have both Lead Paint and Asbestos? Surely even the most rusted on Labor supporter thinks something has gone wrong here. No one is being held accountable for the multiple disasters that have hit public education in Kambah. Greens and Lib politicians need to stand up for once.

One of the reasons ACT Government said they needed to close 3 primary schools in Kambah and build a new Namadgi super school was to remediate building issues such as lead paint etc in the older Kambah primary schools Mt Neighbour, Urambi and Village Creek primary schools. Plus tear down the old Kambah High.
Now they’re telling us the newer Namadgi super school on the site of old Kambah High is on the list with all the bad stuff.

Surely they didn’t just close the Kambah Schools to save money and sell the land off to property developers. That would never happen would it? Surely it was purely about better educating our kids.

Marc Blackmore Marc Blackmore 5:18 am 20 Mar 21

Bonded asbestos is the most common and stable.type of asbestos you can find. It is safe when not abused ( don’t dry cut or grind). Get educated and stop losing your mind people

Kristine Evans Kristine Evans 11:21 pm 19 Mar 21

Wow just wow.

Corey Karl Corey Karl 10:26 pm 19 Mar 21

But stage 2 of the light rail will be here soon

Rainer Busacker Rainer Busacker 7:51 pm 19 Mar 21

What do you expect from a Labour, spent all the revenue on self endurance such as the train. Now have to look for another cash cow to fund some other indulgence. Community and our children's safety has a low priority.

    John Kooyman John Kooyman 9:59 pm 19 Mar 21

    Rainer Busacker The MOST IMPORTANT things always seem to get the lowest priority by agenda promoting, longevity seeking, self serving politicos which, unfortunately, ACT Government apparently has plenty of. This has been a reported problem for over 20 years and again they MUST (????) discuss, debate, consider, basically just give lip service and we live in hope they will actually fix the problem ASAP ! Dteam on !

    Jo Hann Jo Hann 9:17 am 20 Mar 21

    Rainer Busacker I'm not sure what you imagine another party would have done differently. Please explain what they have done that makes it seem to you that safety is a "low priority" as you say.

    Rainer Busacker Rainer Busacker 10:05 am 20 Mar 21

    Jo Hann if the LP was in touch with the communitIy and its concerns about Asbestos and Lead paint, then it would have had an ongoing program over the past 20 years to remedy it as part of their maintenance program. Instead they have spent money on less important,, non urgent projekty such As public art, duplication of bike lanes where bike tracking areály exist and going for Light Rail where Electric/battery powered Buses would have been more cost effective.

    Jo Hann Jo Hann 11:41 am 20 Mar 21

    Rainer Busacker you cannot "remedy" sheet asbestos and lead paint as "part of a the maintenance program".

CBR Tweets

Sign up to our newsletter

 Top
Region Group Pty Ltd

Search across the site