17 October 2012

So what is the difference between Liberal and Labor?

| johnboy
Join the conversation
25
underpants gnomes

As this election has unfolded it’s become clear we’re looking at two radically different approaches to persuading the electorate.

The Liberals are being deliberately down in the weeds. Extra wheely bin this, more parking that, road duplication there.

Labor on the other hand is all about the aspirations. A good example of that is childhood obesity.

Am I agin’ it? Sure why not.

How much am I willing to pay to tackle it? Not sure.

What freedoms am I willing to forgo to free the Government’s hand on the issue? Whoa whoa up there cowboy!

Fortunately ACT Labor doesn’t actually want to be taken seriously on these issues. Their policy initiatives have no real hope of dealing with the matters they raise. Think “No Waste 2010” or “Housing Affordability”. We’re talking government by underpants gnomes here:

It comes down to whether you like big dreams or incremental improvements.

Battista comes to mind:

We fought against the empire of heaven. We were – that I will not deny – vanquished in that conflict: yet the great intention was not lacking in nobility. Something or other gave them victory; to us remains the glory of dauntless daring. And even if my troop fell thence vanquished, yet to have atempted a lofty enterprise is still a trophy.

I like my football team to play like rebel angels. I’m not sure it’s what’s called for from a Government.

Some of you might prefer a Government that chooses its battles carefully and exerts itself on matters it can reasonably hope to succeed with.

That’s up to you as a voter.

But if it helps that’s the clearest difference I can see.

Join the conversation

25
All Comments
  • All Comments
  • Website Comments
LatestOldest

How can you tell when a politician is lying?

Their lips are moving.

watto23 said :

bd84 said :

One has screwed us over for the past 11 years and the other one hasn’t? I guess it depends on whether Canberrans want to live with the same tired administration for another 4 years.

In a small jurisdiction like the ACT, there’s never going to be much between the two and all we need is a semi-decent alternative. Oppositions are always a risk because they are untried and aren’t provided full information to put up fully planned policies, but sometime the Government needs to be sent a message.

We’ve seen 10+ year old governments, both liberal and labor at state and federal level become old and tired in recent years. I think those jurisdictions have benefitted to some extent by giving the governments the flick for a new set of hands to fix some things up. Time for a change me thinks..

Not going to happen. There are no independants that are likely to win a seat and support the libs. Even Labor in a labor town has only gained a majority in the ACT gov once from memory (2004 election).

The “Osbourne Independents” did support the Liberals in the past before a previous election and a minor party with a chance of a member being elected into the last spot has said on WIN local news it will support the Liberals after the current election.

So we all whinge about it, but still accept the two party system. Or the greens if we want to absolve ourselves for our over-sized, energy consuming houses and gas-guzzling SUVs.

Instead we chose between Katy’s dodgy hospital figures (which still have us last), Zed’s three word slogan and the greens pushing for Government funded IVF for blind Iraqi refugee lesbians.

At least there’s the sausage sizzle to look forward to

dpm said :

bd84 said :

…. We’ve seen 10+ year old governments, both liberal and labor at state and federal level become old and tired in recent years. I think those jurisdictions have benefitted to some extent by giving the governments the flick for a new set of hands to fix some things up. Time for a change me thinks..

Yep, Queenslanders are *loving* their new dictator! Hahahaha!

http://www.theaustralian.com.au/national-affairs/state-politics/campbell-newman-weakens-same-sex-reforms/story-e6frgczx-1226393619424

http://reneweconomy.com.au/2012/newman-wipes-climate-and-clean-energy-off-queensland-map-48670

http://www.smh.com.au/business/mining-and-resources/shock-royalty-gouge-on-coal-20120911-25px6.html

http://www.brisbanetimes.com.au/queensland/newman-to-scrap-7000-first-home-owner-grant-20120910-25mvu.html

http://www.abc.net.au/news/2012-10-11/labor-blames-newman-for-grim-jobs-numbers/4308198/?site=tropic

http://www.brisbanetimes.com.au/queensland/2700-jobs-to-go-from-queensland-health-20120907-25iad.html

http://www.abc.net.au/news/2012-09-14/no-qld-public-servants-sacked-newman-says/4261346

http://theconversation.edu.au/planning-changes-to-accelerate-queensland-coast-development-10125

http://www.brisbanetimes.com.au/queensland/newman-to-water-down-fluoride-rule-20120919-266og.html

http://www.couriermail.com.au/news/queensland/no-one-to-lose-in-breastscreen-change/story-e6freoof-1226442891276

That’s the sort of change we need: cutting services and jobs, while stuffing the environment and ripping off mining (before the Feds do!)… Bring it ON! Hahahaha!
(I’m not saying ACT Libs would do any of this, just that your idea of ‘change’ hasn’t been all benefit in this case….)

…and a switch to a Lib local government here would bring us into line with the rest of them (bar SA & TAS).

Multiple Choice:

Disenchantment with Lib local governments all over Australia will be…

a. helpful to Tony Abbott

b. a handicap for Tony Abbott

in the next Federal election?

poetix said :

To borro somewhat from one John Ono Lennon, ‘what would happen if we held an election and no-one turned up?’

borro….

*sigh*

I thought it was about the donkey vote, but I was too polite to correct the ‘o’.

Assumptions only make an ass out of you and me….

bd84 said :

One has screwed us over for the past 11 years and the other one hasn’t? I guess it depends on whether Canberrans want to live with the same tired administration for another 4 years.

In a small jurisdiction like the ACT, there’s never going to be much between the two and all we need is a semi-decent alternative. Oppositions are always a risk because they are untried and aren’t provided full information to put up fully planned policies, but sometime the Government needs to be sent a message.

We’ve seen 10+ year old governments, both liberal and labor at state and federal level become old and tired in recent years. I think those jurisdictions have benefitted to some extent by giving the governments the flick for a new set of hands to fix some things up. Time for a change me thinks..

Not going to happen. There are no independants that are likely to win a seat and support the libs. Even Labor in a labor town has only gained a majority in the ACT gov once from memory (2004 election).

bd84 said :

…. We’ve seen 10+ year old governments, both liberal and labor at state and federal level become old and tired in recent years. I think those jurisdictions have benefitted to some extent by giving the governments the flick for a new set of hands to fix some things up. Time for a change me thinks..

Yep, Queenslanders are *loving* their new dictator! Hahahaha!

http://www.theaustralian.com.au/national-affairs/state-politics/campbell-newman-weakens-same-sex-reforms/story-e6frgczx-1226393619424

http://reneweconomy.com.au/2012/newman-wipes-climate-and-clean-energy-off-queensland-map-48670

http://www.smh.com.au/business/mining-and-resources/shock-royalty-gouge-on-coal-20120911-25px6.html

http://www.brisbanetimes.com.au/queensland/newman-to-scrap-7000-first-home-owner-grant-20120910-25mvu.html

http://www.abc.net.au/news/2012-10-11/labor-blames-newman-for-grim-jobs-numbers/4308198/?site=tropic

http://www.brisbanetimes.com.au/queensland/2700-jobs-to-go-from-queensland-health-20120907-25iad.html

http://www.abc.net.au/news/2012-09-14/no-qld-public-servants-sacked-newman-says/4261346

http://theconversation.edu.au/planning-changes-to-accelerate-queensland-coast-development-10125

http://www.brisbanetimes.com.au/queensland/newman-to-water-down-fluoride-rule-20120919-266og.html

http://www.couriermail.com.au/news/queensland/no-one-to-lose-in-breastscreen-change/story-e6freoof-1226442891276

That’s the sort of change we need: cutting services and jobs, while stuffing the environment and ripping off mining (before the Feds do!)… Bring it ON! Hahahaha!
(I’m not saying ACT Libs would do any of this, just that your idea of ‘change’ hasn’t been all benefit in this case….)

One has screwed us over for the past 11 years and the other one hasn’t? I guess it depends on whether Canberrans want to live with the same tired administration for another 4 years.

In a small jurisdiction like the ACT, there’s never going to be much between the two and all we need is a semi-decent alternative. Oppositions are always a risk because they are untried and aren’t provided full information to put up fully planned policies, but sometime the Government needs to be sent a message.

We’ve seen 10+ year old governments, both liberal and labor at state and federal level become old and tired in recent years. I think those jurisdictions have benefitted to some extent by giving the governments the flick for a new set of hands to fix some things up. Time for a change me thinks..

colourful sydney racing identity2:31 pm 17 Oct 12

poetix said :

To borro somewhat from one John Ono Lennon, ‘what would happen if we held an election and no-one turned up?’

borro….

*sigh*

I thought it was about the donkey vote, but I was too polite to correct the ‘o’.

well played.

poetix said :

To borro somewhat from one John Ono Lennon, ‘what would happen if we held an election and no-one turned up?’

borro….

*sigh*

I thought it was about the donkey vote, but I was too polite to correct the ‘o’.

That is, the first ‘o’. Sigh.

After a while, the amazing privilege of being able to check one’s comments and correct them begins to pale. (But I won’t tell any of the more recent converts.)

And, without converting myself into classroom suck, I thought the article by JB above was chokkas with insight.

(I’m not even after free stuff, as I have War of the Worlds tickets…)

colourful sydney racing identity2:01 pm 17 Oct 12

colourful sydney racing identity said :

To borro somewhat from one John Ono Lennon, ‘what would happen if we held an election and no-one turned up?’

borro….

*sigh*

You know if you were a subscriber to this site you could have fixed that before anyone noticed? #smugnewsubscriber

Done.

JB – do I get free stuff now or do I have to start the ‘how to win friends and influence people CSRI style – subscribe to RA’ thread?

To borro somewhat from one John Ono Lennon, ‘what would happen if we held an election and no-one turned up?’

borro….

*sigh*

I thought it was about the donkey vote, but I was too polite to correct the ‘o’.

As I see it we have Labor on one side trying to gloss over 12 years of cost blowouts on public works projects and general financial incompetence, and the Libs trying their darnedest to scare everyone that Labor will send us to the wall with rate rises, while placating with token gestures of improved public amenity.

All I’m interested in is a Government that can focus on improving basic services, manage costs and spend less time aspiring to ideals beyond their grasp.

colourful sydney racing identity1:39 pm 17 Oct 12

To borro somewhat from one John Ono Lennon, ‘what would happen if we held an election and no-one turned up?’

borro….

*sigh*

You know if you were a subscriber to this site you could have fixed that before anyone noticed? #smugnewsubscriber

The Libs have rebranded themselves as the new Labor. Not actually hard to do, as Labor appears to have lost the plot, with fractured ideals that no longer speak for the working people. As a former long time Labor voter, I am sorry to say that the Labor party are like ‘children, tossed to and fro by the waves and carried about by every wind of doctrine, by human cunning, by craftiness in deceitful schemes’. If only they had just got on with the business of running the joint properly over the last 12 years, people would not be so disgruntled and disaffected.

HenryBG said :

Deref said :

What’s the difference between Laboral and Libour? Bugger all.

Not true.

Labour gets stuff done, but they don’t manage expenditure too well (eg, AMC and Australia’s worst-performing hospital), leading to the blowout in rates.

The Libs get less done, but they are likely to keep costs down for us.

As far as sacking public servants goes – that wouldn’t be an efficient way of doing it – all they have to do is terminate the army of parasites on $100-$400 contracts and consultancies and vastly more money will be saved without losing any jobs.

The whole ‘Labour spends more’ thing is an utter myth, it’s proof of nothing more than the idea that if you keep repeating something often enough then people will start believing it.

Ditto with ‘Libs get less done’. I daresay the only reason the Libs get less stuff done is because they’ve had less time in government (in local terms anyway – on a Federal level it’s because they’re a pack of reactionary conservatives, and reactionary conservatives don’t believe in *doing* things, they’re more interested in stopping things happening because change is scary and immoral).

bitzermaloney1:19 pm 17 Oct 12

Deref said :

What’s the difference between Laboral and Libour? Bugger all.

+1 …. oh an Laboral have the little green whingy sister sitting behind them.

Deref said :

What’s the difference between Laboral and Libour? Bugger all.

Not true.

Labour gets stuff done, but they don’t manage expenditure too well (eg, AMC and Australia’s worst-performing hospital), leading to the blowout in rates.

The Libs get less done, but they are likely to keep costs down for us.

As far as sacking public servants goes – that wouldn’t be an efficient way of doing it – all they have to do is terminate the army of parasites on $100-$400 contracts and consultancies and vastly more money will be saved without losing any jobs.

What’s the difference between Laboral and Libour? Bugger all.

Jim Jones said :

A pox on both their houses.

Ergo, a pox on all our houses, as we shall all suffer another four years of these braying nincimpoops. Regardless of who wins.

Jim Jones said :

The big difference between Liberal and Labor is that the Liberal Party is campaigning using a crude fear campaign (rates will triple) and that the Labor party is campaigning using a different crude fear campaign (job cuts in the public service).

A pox on both their houses.

To be fair though, what would you campaign with if you were either of these parties?
Because saying “look at me, I’ll give you this small thing” won’t compare to the other guy saying one of their actual campaigns. The effect is just so much less severe. So given that you would be assuming the other party would be using the big guns, you would be crazy to hold back with yours.

Jim Jones said :

A pox on both their houses.

Looking at some of their candidates, I fear a pox already exists…

The big difference between Liberal and Labor is that the Liberal Party is campaigning using a crude fear campaign (rates will triple) and that the Labor party is campaigning using a different crude fear campaign (job cuts in the public service).

A pox on both their houses.

neanderthalsis10:45 am 17 Oct 12

Maybe I’m not your average Canberra voter, being more realistic than idealistic. But I prefer a govt that will get things done, not make lofty statements and proclamations about how they will make me make my life better, whether I like it or not.

Katy’s lunch box inspectors are less likely to earn my vote than a green wheelie bin. That said, I am disappointed that the Libs haven’t been a little more visionary but I guess they feel they are on safer ground promising basic services rather than stopping waste altogether and ending the scourge of fat kids, who are the root of all society’s evil. (I was an obese child before it became mainstream, does this make me a hipster?)

Daily Digest

Want the best Canberra news delivered daily? Every day we package the most popular Riotact stories and send them straight to your inbox. Sign-up now for trusted local news that will never be behind a paywall.

By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.