25 July 2024

Baby recession a sign of the times that our leaders can't ignore

| Ian Bushnell
Join the conversation
5
karinya house mothers day gala

Hard times: Fewer babies is a demographic time bomb. Photo: File.

New figures showing Australia is in a baby recession should ring alarm bells for the nation’s leaders.

Births across the country fell by 4.6 per cent year on year. The number of births in 2023 was the lowest since 2006.

The drop in births was more pronounced in the capital cities, with Sydney births dropping to 60,860, down 8.6 per cent from 2019, Melbourne with 56,270 births was down 7.3 per cent, Perth with 25,020 births was down 6.0 per cent, and Brisbane with 30,250 births was down 4.3 per cent.

During 2023, 289,100 babies were born in Australia, a significant reduction from the 2021 post-lockdown spike, which saw 315,200 babies born.

READ ALSO Rescue group goes to greatest of heights to find forever homes for its dogs in need

It’s not hard to understand why couples are putting off plans to start a family as interest rates and cost-of-living increases erode incomes and confidence.

While some might be deciding the world is no fit place for children and it’s only going to get worse, and parenthood isn’t for everyone, more are obviously worried about how they could afford them.

Canberra is bucking the trend and being the only capital city to see no drop in births since 2019 (holding steady at 5530 in both 2019 and 2023), which only reinforces the role economic fears are playing in people’s decisions.

Here in the national capital, relatively high incomes, stable employment, and a calmer housing market mean Canberrans feel secure enough to keep reproducing.

The new figures come as the nation’s total fertility rate continues its long-term decline, from more than two children per woman in 2008 to 1.6 in 2023.

This is a genuinely depressing state of affairs that will have social, economic and political consequences if left unaddressed.

While some will point to recent economic bad news, this is just piled on top of decades of bad policies that have pushed home ownership out of the reach of an increasing number of Australians, kept wages low and contributed to the rising costs of basic services.

Recent research from consultant 89 Degrees East found 61 per cent of Australians think the dream of home ownership is pretty much dead for young Australians, and 75 per cent of renters agreed.

Families need secure homes, and that has become an ever-decreasing possibility for many.

Anxiety about housing, jobs and pay is obviously wreaking havoc with the hopes and aspirations of young people and probably their love lives.

While efforts to increase the supply of housing are underway, if government was serious about the cost, it would do as independent economist Saul Eastlake advises: when you are in a hole – stop digging.

That means scrapping policies that help boost prices, such as negative gearing and capital gains tax concessions, and political quick fixes, such as first home owner grants.

The housing industry will also have to look at more innovation including cheaper construction methods, including prefabrication.

While cannibalising the suburbs to build more homes is already happening, cheaper alternative sites in the regions must also come into play. That will require transport links such as new fast train lines (high-speed rail might be too much to ask for) and localised job creation.

The capital cities are already sprawling into unmanageable megalopolises as it is.

Government should also be worried about the demographic time bomb a declining birth rate poses for the future workforce and taxpayers who are expected to support Australians who are living longer.

Plugging the gap with migration only ignores the issue.

READ ALSO What is a minimum rental standard? Consultation aims to find out

Young Australians may think they can wait for better times. If only their fertility would cooperate.

It’s a recipe for missed opportunity, grief and loneliness.

Politically, it’s a situation ripe for anger, alienation and resentment – and exploitation by extremist elements.

We are bequeathing lower standards of living, less social mobility, and an economic dead-end.

It’s no wonder young people are just saying no.

Are our leaders capable of building an economy that works for them and restores their hope?

Join the conversation

5
All Comments
  • All Comments
  • Website Comments
LatestOldest
Incidental Tourist8:22 am 31 Jul 24

To have more babies a family should be able to live on one income. A majority of the cost of living (housing, childcare, medical, service) is local taxes. We need to undo the harmful tax reform to reverse day to day local tax burden. Politicians have to stop buying things we don’t need with money we don’t have to build utopia town for the last person surviving. Another important component is policy focus on strengthening and supporting families. For too long the focus was anything but a family. “Family benefit check” should be in the centre of accepting or rejecting of all policies.

HiddenDragon7:35 pm 30 Jul 24

The KPMG report which prompted this article suggested that the efforts of developers and their collaborators in elected politics to herd more families into cramped accommodation because “we have to build up, not out” is a significant factor in this worrying statistic, so there should be much more pushback against the densification zealots and spruikers –

https://www.abc.net.au/news/2024-07-24/cost-of-living-pressures-melbourne-birth-rates/104135890

The ever-increasing reliance of governments on property-related revenues to fund waste, incompetence, duplication of effort and shameless vote-buying also needs to be put under the microscope.

The burdening of young Australians, from quite an early age, with climate change gloom and doom and guilt about living on stolen land in a “white, colonial, racist, settler society” (etc.) are not exactly conducive to positive feelings about life and the urge to reproduce, so anyone in a position of authority who cares about the falling birth rate should also be reflecting on the wisdom of that indoctrination.

These days who talks about children as a blessing or a gift? It seems the prevailing narrative is very negative, and children seen as an obstacle to material wealth and unlimited leisure. Women too often see birthing and raising children as a hindrance to career and wealth profession. Even the idea that raising children is ‘not real work’ is a sad attitude that further devalues child rearing. These deeper societal mindsets along with the economic and existential fears that abound are terrible Petri dish in which life simply is not flourishing. We need visionary political leaders who care more about our civilisation than solely the economy.

Stephen Saunders7:37 am 26 Jul 24

If you don’t want a local baby recession, then don’t support the radical Labor program of population replacement, which is crushing living standards and housing affordability.

One million migration in two years. 80% of population growth from immigration. These are simply unheard-of numbers. But if you surface it, ABC Laura Tingle is there, to flash you the racist card. Adam Bandt brands you a “migrant basher” on a “race to the bottom”.

Daily Digest

Want the best Canberra news delivered daily? Every day we package the most popular Riotact stories and send them straight to your inbox. Sign-up now for trusted local news that will never be behind a paywall.

By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.