12 December 2024

Has Canberra become a better place? Yes, a city can't stand still

| Ian Bushnell
Join the conversation
52
National Arboretum

For a better perspective of Canberra, the view from the National Arboretum is always enlightening. Photos: Michelle Kroll.

In 2024, is Canberra a better or worse city to live compared to a decade ago?

That’s a question ABC Breakfast radio put to listeners this week. The peg was that the decade coincided with Andrew Barr’s ascension to the Chief Ministership. This added a political touch to it and inevitably attracted a few haters – and the ABC demographic also meant nostalgia was at play – but it did make me think about the city’s progress.

For some, the city has grown too big, the towers of the town centres too many and the traffic too busy.

They worry that infrastructure and services, such as keeping the grass cut and parks tidy, haven’t been able to cope with the change.

Then there were the expected beefs about hospitals, where there are signs that, finally, things might be turning around.

READ ALSO ACT leads the way in energy-efficient homes, says new report

While the Barr Government’s performance is open to debate – and we did have an election a few weeks ago for people to pass judgment – the fact is that no city can stand still, especially one that has evolved from its role as the national capital to regional hub.

Canberra is no longer a place exposed to the extremes of the elements where politicians and public servants are forced to live, and others may visit but scoff at any thought of making a home there.

When our little family arrived in late 1995, we were amazed that more people had not discovered the place. Australia’s best-kept secret, Canberrans said, let’s keep it that way.

Well, the secret is well and truly out, and young people are not automatically leaving as soon as they can for the metropolises on the coast. And if they do, a fair few are coming back.

Mr Barr is driven by the desire to make Canberra a place where young people do not want to leave – that means jobs, recreation and, importantly, more affordable housing.

Alinga Street light rail stop

A city on the move. Light rail is important infrastructure for a growing national capital.

While there are constant concerns about development encroaching on the bush capital and the loss of the garden suburb ethos, the city has to evolve to meet the challenges of a growing population.

Unfortunately, the housing price boom of the past few decades, helped along by appallingly short-sighted federal policies, means the house and garden dream is beyond many, even with the highest average salaries in the country.

That leads us to density and infill, and the challenges of doing so without paving paradise.

While the town centres could boast more green space and community facilities, the residential development there is bringing thousands of people into what were places in danger of becoming ghost towns.

A decade ago, the National Arboretum was only just getting started; now, it is a magnificent piece of public green infrastructure that no one can imagine Canberra being without.

The ACT leads the way in sustainability – in its homes and offices, the energy transition and its car fleet.

In 1995, the city centre was covered in the wasted space of surface car parks, and two decades later, there were still plenty. The last of them is about to go under development in the form of office precincts, a new theatre, a convention centre and an entertainment pavilion.

These are good things that will provide a more dynamic and diverse economy in the city and broaden entertainment and dining options for everybody.

READ ALSO Two new towers to add 400 apartments to Belconnen Town Centre

Over the past 30 years, Canberra has developed one of the country’s finest food and wine offerings in a city that remains accessible, especially when compared to the rat races of Sydney, Melbourne and now Brisbane, my hometown.

That ease of travel and freedom of movement are among Canberra’s greatest assets, which is why public transport projects, including light rail, are integral to its future.

It remains a privilege to be so close to world-class cultural institutions.

Not everything is rosy. Canberra suffers from the same problems that beset other cities: inequality is growing, the government struggles to keep pace with growth, housing is still way too expensive, some of its architecture is terrible and constant vigilance is required when it comes to planning and maintaining our green spaces.

But whoever would have been Chief Minister, Canberra was destined to grow and change and could not stay as it was.

Join the conversation

52
All Comments
  • All Comments
  • Website Comments
LatestOldest

Canberra isn’t perfect. No place is. But it is a much better place now than it was a decade or two ago. There is a lot more going for it and way more diversity. Please don’t stop now. We need to continue to progress and be better still. We live in the best city in Australia and I feel lucky to call it home. We need more people to call it theirs.

What complete and utter rubbish.

‘Youth’s’ now have;

Ice skating philip;
Rollerfit anu & Belconnen;
Bowling Belconnen kingpin Tuggeranong
Pools at gungahlin stromlo Belconnen philip Dickson, Jamison w/slides ( when reopened )

And;
2 Timezones;
Kingpin amusements;
5+ cinemas, a new imax;
3 Skateparks;
Dozens of Outdoor playgrounds;
3+ lakes and rec area;
Mountain bike riding;
Nature parks, hiking;
Central Water park playground;
20+ Airconditioned gyms;
Youth centres; theatres; libraries; monuments; and plenty more

if a ‘youth’ has done all their homework, and chores; and their casual jobs; and kissed their mother, I doubt they’d have much free time that can’t be filled with one of the above.

If they did still have spare time to be bored I’d hazard a guess that their family is VERY wealthy… in which case it’s time to start volunteering for the less well off ✅

I remember when Canberra had an ice-skating rink, roller-skating rink. bowling ally’s, and a drive Inn. there is hardly any entertainment for children and youth now so they spend time roaming the streets bored. I also remember the days when drug use was everywhere but hardly any homeless.

CANBERRA HAS GOTTEN A LOT WOURSE OVER THE YEARS ESPECIALLY FOR YOUTH.

“I also remember the days when drug use was everywhere but hardly any homeless.”

Eh? You are advocating widespread drug use as a cure for homelessness?

I am prepared to agree that education appears to have, as you put it, gotten a lot wourse.

The ACT has the worst per capita access to swimming facilities in Australia. Phillip Pool is being lost to a misconceived attempt to get the private sector to deliver public good and community facilities. Geocon is going to make a fortune at the expense of the locals. Developers have way too much power in this country

Canberra has been a great place to raise kids. I’d love to see the government not just replace the canopy but expand it. There’s nothing better than walking around the bush capital and seeing all the bird and animal life. I’d also love to see Canberra get a world-class stadium and entertainment precinct. It kinda sucks that major artists and shows will play Newcastle but not the national capital.

HiddenDragon8:42 pm 13 Dec 24

The last decade has largely been a continuation and acceleration of the broad trends we have seen since self government, much of which has been about trying to pay our own way, and dealing with our share of the “Big Australia” idiocy – which has created economic bloat, rather than solid economic growth of the sort which allows for sustainable improvements in living standards.

So many of the disappointments about what used to be and/or might have been flow from those fiscal realities, made worse by the fact that the town has been run, for the most part, by people who have a special gift for stuff-ups and for finding the most expensive way of doing things, even when the outcomes are reasonably good.

To add insult to injury, and this has become particularly apparent over the last decade, we have been subject to incessant gaslighting by an alliance of those who want to extract as much money as possible from the growth of the city (by making us pay more and more for less and less) and useful idiots who seem to think that big city costs, pressures and loss of amenity will somehow make us more virtuous and “grown up” – without ever doing anything more than the superficial about the inherent blandness and smug parochialism of the place.

The new arrangements in the Legislative Assembly offer some small hope – Labor governing in minority might (fingers crossed) be less wasteful and ideological.

Having moved here from the beautiful northern beaches of Sydney in 2000 I thought I’d stay for 6 months but fell in love with the place. There’s still much I love about it which is why I stay despite the exorbitant rates, terrible public transport, poor access to decent healthcare, filthy lake, uncared for trees, lack of public toilets and completely missing focus on the needs of pedestrians as well as an atrocious local government. What do I love?

It is still a beautiful city if a little uncared for in places, with orange plastic in so many places at once as no work is completed quickly. We have amazing public institutions with free entry, some beautiful large leafy parks in older areas and mostly a very polite population. In Sydney you walk past a building site and get raucous or abusive comments, whilst here it’s ‘Gday!’ or ‘Good morning’. There are lots of festivals or outdoor events, although sadly we’ve lost a few since covid.

There used to be jazz & blues concerts in the Sculpture Garden where people could picnic and drink wine. Free concerts at the High Court have not been revived. Too many events are not accessible by public transport from home to event and back home again. There’s been a huge rise in poverty and homelessness, with public housing diminished and expensive flats booming. The food is still good.

So, swings and roundabouts. Good and bad in the changes, mostly good for the wealthy and mostly bad for those who less financially well-off.

@psycho
Absolutely agree … with progress and growth comes change – some good and some not so good.

wildturkeycanoe4:19 pm 13 Dec 24

“Canberra has developed one of the country’s finest food and wine offerings in a city that remains accessible”. I disagree. We just did a spontaneous trip to Cabramatta yesterday and were astounded by the quality and quantity of food compared to here. It was also much more affordable I have to say. We have watched over the years as our favorite food stores in Belconnen have dwindled away into the abyss. The replacements are just too “health and lifestyle” oriented. Where’s the delicious MSG filled, “bad for you” food that doesn’t require selling your youngest child?

This is a pap piece. Barr and Rattenbury have wrecked Canberra by growing it faster than infrastructure like housing, hospital facilities, maintenance, etc can cope. To make things worse they have charged excessive rates, taxes and charges to pay for an out of date and economically expensive light rail system. They should have gone long ago but for an inept Liberal Opposition.

The tax reform came well before the light rail.

of course a city can stand still

The problem is some areas have become much worse because they have been neglected by Mr Barr.

Only have to look at my old suburb of Kambah. 3 government schools closed and replaced by the poorly performing Superschool. My mother’s bus stop removed and now the irregular bus service meanders via Weston Creek. Sports ovals and kids playgrounds in the suburb replaced by high density housing and so much community infrastructure and facilities have completely decayed or are a decade past replacement.

Where I live in northern Woden isn’t much better. So many community facilities and social infrastructure replaced by high rise property developers who don’t care if a unit sits empty or if the renters no longer have access to facilities.

A lot of the people who think Canberra is a better place to live or work, are in the areas that the government have thrown money and new infrastructure and services at. Areas that gained, from other people’s losses.

I wouldn’t have come back to Canberra a few years ago if it hadn’t transformed from the sterile, one-dimensional collection of suburbs in search of a city it was when I, along with most of my cohort, fled at the end of the 70s. Since then I’ve lived for over a decade in each of Australia’s two largest cities, as well as a major European capital. Thankfully the dead hand of the National Capital Development Commission has been somewhat lifted, although we’re still subject to the outdated aesthetic and environmental values of the National Capital Authority, which appears determined to protect the NCDC’s legacy of motorways lined with surface carparks in the Parliamentary Triangle, Canberra’s dead heart. After living in Rome, where trams with overhead power run past the Colosseum, the heritage concerns of the NCA and its dwindling band of supporters appear comic.

It’s far worse. In 2000 I rented a perfectly decent 1 bedroom apartment (0 star energy rated) in Lyneham for $90 per week. I could afford to get a coffee and wedges at Tilleys and only work 2 nights per week while I went to uni. Now the cost of living is astronomical funding ideological views which make peoples’ day to day lives far worse.

When society was based on better ideas – giving it a better understanding of what the good life truly means – it would have laughed at such childish markers.

The good life means a life spent in pursuit of the virtues, including being loving, honest, generous, courageous, loyal, self-sacrificing and so on; and when we look at how Canberra stacks up against all that, we see that it’s as good as sh*t its pants.

Loving: the divorce rate is through the roof; parents send their kids off to get raised by strangers, while giving their old parents over to nursing homes, etc

Honest: “he’s holding a mirror up to our rottenness! Bigot! Conspiracy theorist!”

Generous: charity starts at home and Canberrans – the biggest and stinkiest globalists of them all – can’t even look after their country first, telling us all we need to know about their feigned generosity.

Courageous: Consider the Canberra clowns’ behaviour during COVID, for instance. Totally supported wrecking the entire globe 100 times over, so that we could aim for perfect safety and nothing else. And don’t get me started on their beloved hate laws and the like, because people are now too frightened to be looked at sideways.

Loyal: see above under “loving” where I point out the size of the divorce rate, and how keeping your word means nothing at all. And don’t forget about them selling Australia out.

Self-sacrificing: see above, once more, where I point out the decadence in the divorce rate, where uninspired parents split simply because they ‘feel bored’, the welfare of their children be damned.

There are so many more examples of Canberra’s shame; every progressive ‘freedom’ or control taking its toll on every virtue

Oh, this drivel is quite a treat, especially the revisionist history of whatever this nonsense:

“Courageous: Consider the Canberra clowns’ behaviour during COVID, for instance. Totally supported wrecking the entire globe 100 times over, so that we could aim for perfect safety and nothing else. And don’t get me started on their beloved hate laws and the like, because people are now too frightened to be looked at sideways.”

And whilst there were plenty of things wrong with COVID policy that we should learn from, no government anywhere got it perfectly right, wrecking the globe….lol good one.

What I most enjoy about, the far right besides their refusal to deal with reality when it doesn’t suit their narrative (I mean seriously how they function in society when everything they don’t like is either an outrage or “fake news”) is their absurd obsession with moral purity/superiority whilst typically displaying none themselves.

“There are so many more examples of Canberra’s shame; every progressive ‘freedom’ or control taking its toll on every virtue”

The far right loves to talk about freedom but they’re the first to want to deny it to anyone different to them or their worldview. If they truly believed in “freedom” they’d accept people are different and should largely be left alone to get on with things.

PS. Criticism of the far right’s bad ideas and dodgy thinking isn’t a denial of freedom but the far right confusing it with a denial of “freedom” shows how thin-skinned they are.

Change us the only constant, but poor change needs to be challenged. Don’t go back 10 years, go back to when Labor came into power.

Since then, and this undeniable, Canberra’s health, education public housing and public transport have gone backwards. All on top of massive rates, services and other charges increasing ridiculously..
You have a CM hell bent on conforming Canberra into his dream, which ignores the suburbs, particularly those south of the lake, lies or at the very least, hides the truth from Canberrans, particularly in regard to fiscal matters.

Canberra has gone from best to almost worse on all things that matter, and that is Labor’s fault, no one else’s.

Gregg Heldon7:43 am 13 Dec 24

I believe that Canberra is not as great as 10 years ago. Or 1995. Or even 1975 when I moved here as an 8 year old.
It’s a town where it’s easy to feel very lonely, very isolated.
The city has always been a bit snobbish, a bit judgemental. Here in Canberra, it’s not so much about your address but about your job title, but I think it’s a lot worse now.
It’s harder to feel “at home” and comfortable here than it ever has. For me anyway. I hardly ever leave the house, apart from taking my dogs for their daily walk but, even then, people look me up and down.
It’s hard to be yourself here, unless you’re half my age and trying to find your place in this world.
A bigger city means change and I accept that. Although Canberra skyscraper architecture is particularly hideous, especially compared to other cities, but I personally think that there is a large cohort of people that are getting left behind.
Just my experience. I loved Canberra in my 20s and 30s. Not so much now in my 50s.

Capital Retro8:41 am 13 Dec 24

I agree Gregg. Canberra is a very socio-economically divided city.
It’s not helped by the addiction its people have for social media.
I was in a doctor’s waiting room last week and of the 15 odd people there with me I was the only one not staring at a device.
An old lady with a walker tried to exit the door after her consultation and not one of those 15 people even noticed her let alone got up to assist her.

Shelby Jarromin9:36 am 13 Dec 24

I completely agree Gregg. I too loved Canberra when I moved here in my early 20s. But now in my mid 50s there is very little that I like. It’s lost the relaxed small country town feel it had. Change is OK but development has been virtually left unfettered, to the Territory’s detriment.

@Gregg Heldon
I’d be interested to hear from you which major city in Australia (arguably the world), has not changed markedly over the last decade or so. Perhaps the 20 year old you, is an entitely different person, with different expectations, to the 20 year old today.

I still love living in Canberra, after arriving here over 30 years ago. If you don’t like it that much nowadays, why don’t you find a city/town which is more to your liking?

Gregg Heldon12:09 pm 13 Dec 24

@JustSaying
My Wife’s work is here and is very well paid, so this is still home for the time being.
Of course the world is different to what is was 10 years ago but there are still places that I love around the world just as much now, if not more, than I did then. I’ll use Kuala Lumpur as a City that continues to impress me. It gets things done. I don’t like crowds but I feel okay in KL crowds. Stockholm, Athens, Sydney and London are cities that continue to excite me that I have a lot of affection for. As well as a few others.
I’m glad that you still love Canberra, but it’s not for me anymore.
I also acquired C-PTSD here as a workplace injury and have been pensioned off because of it, so I think there is a small component of that, that affects my feelings towards Canberra. A new start somewhere else may be needed.
I hope that answers your questions and that you weren’t being sarcastic in your comment. I feel your question was genuine, but the tone made me a bit 50/50. Sorry if I misinterpreted that.

@Gregg Heldon
No sarcasm – I just wonder why someone would stay in a place they obviously don’t like. You answered the question = money.

While I haven’t been to Stockholm for over a decade, however, the other cities you mention are crowded high-rise laden, sprawling, urban metropolises – which is not how I would describe Canberra.

Gregg Heldon6:42 pm 13 Dec 24

It’s weird, isn’t it? Those cities actually make me feel calm whereas Canberra doesn’t anymore.

@Gregg Heldon
I think there’s a marked difference between a holiday destination and a home town.

I know a few people who have retired to their “idyllic, dream location”, only to find it was a much better place to visit, than in which to live. For me the absolute epitome of that is New York – I would visit NYC in a heart beat, but have no desire to live there.

Gregg Heldon7:48 pm 15 Dec 24

@JustSaying
Completely agree. My epitome is the Gold Coast. Love visiting. Couldn’t live there. Los Angeles is the same.

Daily Digest

Want the best Canberra news delivered daily? Every day we package the most popular Riotact stories and send them straight to your inbox. Sign-up now for trusted local news that will never be behind a paywall.

By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.