12 September 2024

Liberal overlays show comparable stadiums fit on Acton Waterfront site

| Ian Bushnell
Join the conversation
54

How Commbank Stadium in Parramatta fits on to the Acton Waterfront site, according to the Canberra Liberals.

The Canberra Liberals have hit back at Labor claims its stadium proposal won’t fit on the Acton Waterfront site, providing their own overlays to show otherwise.

On Wednesday, Chief Minister Andrew Barr said the 6.4-hectare site by the lake was too small for what the Liberals were proposing.

Mr Barr said an overlay of CommBank Stadium in Parramattta, one of three comparable facilities quoted by the Liberals, showed a section of it would jut into Lake Burley Griffin.

He said the Liberals had, in effect, shrunk the stadium used in their imagery so it would fit on the site.

He accused the Liberals of not doing any due diligence before submitting their proposal to voters.

READ ALSO Candidates clash on regulation, the economy and a fast train to Sydney in a lively ACT election forum

But Opposition Leader Elizabeth Lee dismissed the claims as desperation from the Chief Minister, saying all three stadiums – CommBank, Townsville and Christchurch, which is still under construction – would fit comfortably.

Today (Thursday), the Liberals provided images showing each of the three stadiums fitting on the site, although it looks tight the way they have been positioned.

According to Christchurch’s post-earthquake Central Recovery Plan, that city’s stadium project sits on a 6ha site. It will stand 36 metres tall at its highest point. The maximum building height at West Basin under the National Capital Plan is 25m.

How a stadium such as Townsville and Christchurch would sit on the Acton Waterfront site. Images: Canberra Liberals.

Mr Barr said resolving planning issues to allow a stadium to be built on the Acton Waterfront site would be a lengthy and fraught process, requiring changes to the National Capital Plan.

The Commonwealth through the National Capital Authority (NCA) will have the deciding say.

The NCA told Region it considered all proposals put forward through the normal assessment processes.

“Amendments to the National Capital Plan are made through an established, transparent process that includes stakeholder and community consultation, and ministerial and parliamentary oversight,” the NCA said.

Under the Australian Capital Territory (Planning and Land Management) Act 1988, the NCA is required to regularly review the National Capital Plan as the national capital grows.

The Liberal proposal prompted public transport advocates to call for it to revoke its decision to ditch light rail stage 2B to Woden.

The Public Transport Association of Canberra (PTCBR) Ryan Hemsley said building a new stadium at West Basin without extending the light rail network across the lake was short-sighted and neglected its significant transport needs.

“A stadium of this scale will attract thousands of visitors. Without high-capacity public transport operating on its own dedicated right of way along the full length of Commonwealth Avenue, the Canberra Liberals are setting our city up for traffic chaos,” he said.

Mr Hemsley urged the Canberra Liberals to develop a comprehensive transport plan for the stadium that included extending light rail to Canberra’s southern suburbs.

Ms Lee was unmoved.

“We thank them for their advice,” she said.

Join the conversation

54
All Comments
  • All Comments
  • Website Comments
LatestOldest

Try a copy-n-paste job using google maps and you’ll find the proposed stadium is about the same size as Bruce Stadium. And where is the large concrete skirt surrounding the proposed stadium. Are there to be exits all around the stadium to allow for the large numbers to leave quickly. and for those who exit north towards Parkes Way – where do they go? Just imagine an emergency evacuation after a bomb threat? Every bit of shrubbery in the area would get trampled. And only one main route to leave the precinct: towards Commonwealth Ave. A few locals walking over the Parkes Way footbridge
By the looks of the proposal, NRL and soccer only plus concerts. AFL and cricket are out, as are track and field events (a la Commonwealth Games)

Fantastic idea. Canberra needs it, let’s get on with it and build it. It would create a fantastic atmosphere in the city when matches are being played there and it would be great for city businesses.

Has Ms Lee asked or done a deal with the NDC yet, just ask’n.

Andrew Cooke4:28 pm 13 Sep 24

It fits perfectly if there’s no footpaths, service roads or carparks outside of the venue. Also if you cut it down in height by about 50%.

It’ll be perfect! Who needs a 30000 seat stadium, we can get by with half of that.

Labor wanted to build over Parkes way anyway. Eolhy not just sink the roads and you have free space

There is plenty of space for footpaths and service roads as Commbank stadium flairs out massively at the top and at ground level is much smaller. Height restrictions are arbitrary by the NCA and, as it would require a national capital plan anyway they’re meaningless. There’s plenty of walking distance carparks in the city, ANU and Parkes already, but if they wanted more they could build a multi-story carpark on one of the old clover leaves.

The idea of a stadium IN the city sounds good (I recall the excitement of hearing the roar of the crowd in Newcastle, UK) but that location looks really too much of a squeeze and when not in use it becomes a dead area. I can’t see why the current stadium can’t be upgraded – unless I missed something.

The stands are too far out from the field, the raking is too shallow and the angle is wrong as it catches the wind.

Canberra Engineer10:02 pm 12 Sep 24

I was going to vote Liberal at this election because I felt we need a change. But this announcement changed my mind. The irony of putting this behemoth by the lake, on the very site that the Liberals when last in power built the failed ‘Futsal Stadium’ still visible today is amazing. It won’t activate this space, it will create a dead zone except for the periods the stadium is in use. Just look at the Docklands Stadium in Melbourne, or countless others. This breaks good urban planning and ignores a myriad of international evidence. You lost my vote Elizabeth Lee, I expected better than this from you.

Labor never wastes money does it. Oh, wait….. Failed HR software anyone???

So light rail is useful for what?

Acton, Bruce, just get it done. Canberra craves a first class entertainment venue and it should be prioritised over the public housing slums being built across the city!

The overlay doesn’t fit anywhere near as well as the artists impression and that is even without the extra open space required around a stadium.

Makes you wonder what the heck Barr was doing when he posted his images of the stadium covering half the basin? Theres clearly heaps of space just build it there, its a great spot!

Gregg Heldon7:46 pm 12 Sep 24

His argument just seems to be a spluttered “But. But”.
All the while being swatted away like an annoying fly.

If you look at his images he deliberately left a moat of empty space around the stadia.

Daily Digest

Want the best Canberra news delivered daily? Every day we package the most popular Riotact stories and send them straight to your inbox. Sign-up now for trusted local news that will never be behind a paywall.

By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.