17 October 2022

More than arrests: How ACT Policing's working to stop recidivist offending and dangerous drivers

| Claire Fenwicke
Join the conversation
Police officer

Commander Linda Champion, Commander Operations ACT Policing AFP. Photo: James Coleman.

“When Matthew died, there was something as a parent in me that just snapped.”

That’s Commander Linda Champion, the woman in charge of ACT Policing’s new task force, Operation Toric.

Matthew was Matthew McLuckie, who was killed in a head-on collision on Hindmarsh Drive in May.

Operation Toric was formed to address recidivist offenders and dangerous driving in the ACT.

Taskforce officers have made more than 90 arrests and laid more than 200 charges since the operation began in August.

But Commander Champion said this was just the “front end” of operations.

“Toric is about getting out, stopping bad behaviour, but that’s short term,” she said.

“This is about informing the future.”

READ ALSO Three dead after two-car collision in Whitlam

The “future” was sitting beside Commander Champion in the form of the operation’s specialist forensic psychologist, Anna*.

She’s worked in Sydney jails and spent five years working at Canberra’s Alexander Maconochie Centre.

“The problem you see with recidivist offenders is if you stop them in the moment, and when you lock them up, that offending stops for as long as that person is in jail,” Anna said.

“But without learning anything about what drives that offender’s behaviour … you’ve got exactly the same person coming out of jail on the other side.”

Anna argued interventions beyond punishment were needed to lessen the likelihood of someone offending again.

The question she’s aiming to answer is this: what can we do to better arm police and the community to change a person’s behaviour in the future?

“We need to lessen the likelihood of them getting to this [offending] space in the first place,” Anna said.

She explained research showed people who generally took criminal risks in their lives were looking to fulfil some sort of need. They had more ‘risk-taking’ personality traits but hadn’t learned how to address specific needs in a socially acceptable way.

“They’re still human and they have the same needs we do,” Anna said.

“It might be that person is being bullied … so how can they take themselves from being the person who is bullied to the person who is feared or revered? To get what looks like respect from peers?

“They think ‘people might follow me because I do crazy stuff’.”

READ ALSO Dangerous drivers have free rein in Canberra’s wild west, committee told

Anna explained most of us had family, friends and others who could teach us how to make lasting and meaningful connections with people.

But for someone who potentially grew up watching violence, arguing and screaming, they could learn a pattern of not knowing how to relate to people or rely on them.

This could lead to low self-worth and confidence, which then, coupled with a need to take risks, could result in a person seeking to fulfil that need in the ‘wrong’ way.

This could be risky drug or alcohol taking, dangerous driving, and more.

“They have to come off the road,” Commander Champion said.

“But at the moment, we have nothing else to offer.”

READ ALSO Be wary of ‘collective outcry’ and focus on evidence-based response to dangerous driving, government told

It also meant typical methods of punishment – such as fines, getting your car impounded or losing your licence – may not work for these individuals.

“Those things fail to modify the behaviour of this group of people who present as our most dangerous risk,” Anna said.

Anna agreed that not everyone should be let off if they committed an offence, but she was researching what could be done before or after the crime to put someone onto a different path.

“Part of deterrence is removing the person doing damage through incarceration, but there’s no behaviour change in that,” she said.

“We have this belief that when they’re back in society they’re not going to do this again … in fact, after one night in jail, their likelihood of entering jail again is automatically greater.

“Putting someone in jail does not make them better.”

It’s hoped Anna’s research could be applied to the offenders targeted by Operation Toric to stop them from coming into so much contact with police.

“We’re hoping this work will help inform what [police] do … but we also want to get together interested parties to do this together,” Commander Champion said.

“Police can always get them off the road, but it doesn’t end there.

“We can’t do all the pieces.”

READ ALSO Three schools offer extra counselling after multiple holiday road fatalities

But Anna’s work could go even further.

There was already talk of how to reach kids in schools to stop them from driving dangerously or getting in the car with someone who was.

“The only thing [younger offenders] generally value are their friends, so we’re telling them, ‘which of your friends do you want dead?'” Commander Champion said.

“As for the people getting into the car, the joy riders, it’s ‘are you prepared not to walk out of that vehicle?’

“If we can’t stop those types of drivers, I want to stop those other kids from hopping into the car with them.”

At the end of the day, the aim of the entire operation for Commander Champion is simple: “We don’t just look at locking up offenders, we look at making it safe in the long term.”

* Anna’s name has been changed to protect her identity.

Join the conversation

All Comments
  • All Comments
  • Website Comments

“But without learning anything about what drives that offender’s behaviour … you’ve got exactly the same person coming out of jail on the other side.”

Anna*, you must be proud of what you learned and accomplished during your time at the AMC. I can only assume that the drop in ACT crime rates in 2021 was due to your hard work and not Covid-19 lockdowns ?

However, you and your colleagues may have dropped the ball on violent crimes and murders in the same period…whoopsie.

Another academic with the answers but no actual application. As for Commander Champion comment that “The only thing [younger offenders] generally value are their friends, so we’re telling them, ‘which of your friends do you want dead?’” tell that to the ones left behind in the car crash while the drivers (generally) run off and save their skins. My daughter has a criminology degree from ANU and I was a former General Duties AFP officer albeit in the 1980s. We have interesting debates involving sociopath behaviour relating to the reality versus the fantasy of law enforcement. This is a long running debate. Good luck Anna and Commander Champion.

William Newby11:54 pm 18 Oct 22

So, an unnamed psychologist claims to have all the answers for thought processes of repeat offenders.
One can only assume she is not using her real name as such IP would be literally worth billions!
Excuse the scepticism here but without the empirically backed evidence, that her profession hangs their hat so squarely upon, this is just another ‘science’ experiment.
For now I’m more comfortable sticking with the good old fashioned, lock them up; if they can’t play nicely banish them from the playground!

norminngunnawalcountry4:57 am 22 Oct 22

Go back and read the article.
>>claims to have all the answers<<
The psych is still researching how to get this working.

Good luck. One startling statistic I read years ago was that a single-digit percentage of unlicenced/unregistered/repeat offenders are responsible for 90+% of road fatalities. If there’s some way to get these people off the roads, I’m all for it.

Daily Digest

Want the best Canberra news delivered daily? Every day we package the most popular Riotact stories and send them straight to your inbox. Sign-up now for trusted local news that will never be behind a paywall.

By submitting your email address you are agreeing to Region Group's terms and conditions and privacy policy.